Medicare Calculations of Direct and Indirect GME
Costs
Medicare now pays hospitals for GME through two payment streams –
direct GME payments and the Indirect Medical Education Adjustment
(IMEA).
Direct GME Payments
Direct payments compensate a teaching hospital for overhead costs
related to GME, and salaries and fringe benefits for residents,
teaching physicians and GME administrative staff.
Before 1985, direct GME payments were not capitated, and could be
increased if a hospital’s direct GME costs increased. Since then,
the payments have been capitated and are now linked to a
"per-resident"amount. The average per-resident amount (APRA) was
calculated in 1985 and has been adjusted for inflation in all
subsequent calculations.
A hospital’s total direct GME payments can be determined by
multiplying APRA by: an inflation adjuster, the number of current
full-time residents, and the proportion of the hospital’s inpatient
days used by Medicare patients. These factors are not as
straightforward as they initially may appear. As Congress has looked
for ways to save money from the Medicare program, it has modified
this formula and the factors in the formula. For the years 1994 and
1995, the inflation adjuster was "frozen" for all non-primary care
specialties. As a result, there are now two inflation adjusters –
one for primary care specialties and another for other
specialties.
A second important change relates to the number of years a
resident has been in training. When a resident is in his/her initial
residency period, which is defined as the minimum number of years
required for initial board eligibility in the first specialty the
resident entered (maximum of five years) the resident is counted as
1.0 Full Time Equivalent (FTE). After the initial residency period,
the resident is counted as a .5 FTE, reducing hospital’s direct
reimbursement for a resident by 50%. Medicare makes an exception for
combined residencies involving primary care specialties such as
internal medicine, pediatrics, family practice, and preventive
medicine.
Finally, the formula for calculating the proportion of Medicare
bed-days to total bed-days needs special considerations as well.
Patients in Medicare managed care plans can be counted in the total
number of bed-days but not in the number of Medicare bed-days. As
more Medicare patients enroll in managed care plans, the proportion
of Medicare bed-days is reduced, and therefore, the total direct
reimbursement is reduced.
Indirect Adjustments
The Indirect Medical Education Adjustment (IMEA) compensates
teaching hospitals for higher operating costs associated with the
presence of a residency program such as more complicated cases,
additional tests ordered by residents as part of the learning
process and reduced patient care productivity by all staff
members.
Calculating the Indirect Medical Education Adjustment (IMEA) is
more complicated than calculating the direct payments because the
factors in the calculation are more complicated. This report will
not explain all the factors that go into IMEA calculations; it will
attempt to provide a general understanding of the calculation
methodology. IMEA formulas are based on statistical estimates
because indirect costs cannot be quantified accurately. For example,
it is difficult to quantify how much patient care productivity is
lost while hospital staff are engaged in supporting the training
program.
The following methodology is only used for hospital departments
that receive Medicare payments. If a hospital or department with a
residency program is exempt from the Medicare program or has limited
involvement in caring for Medicare beneficiaries (e.g., pediatric,
rehabilitation, or psychiatric hospitals or hospital departments),
the methodology for calculating IME payments is done separately from
the Medicare program.
IMEA is a percentage add-on to Medicare payments for patient
care. Medicare classifies patients into Diagnosis-Related Groups
(DRGs) and sets a standard amount for all patients in a particular
DRG. The standard DRG payment is then adjusted for each hospital by
considering how overhead, wages and types of cases vary based on the
hospital’s location (urban hospitals tend to have higher costs and
more complicated cases). These calculations are done for both
teaching and non-teaching hospitals.
As mentioned above, IMEA is calculated by adding a percentage to
each DRG payment at a hospital. The first step in calculating this
percent add-on is determining the hospital’s ratio of individual
residents-to- beds (IRB). When counting the number of residents, a
hospital can only count their full-time equivalent residents who are
working in the hospital’s inpatient or outpatient department. In
some cases, residents assigned to physicians’ clinics can be counted
in this ratio. When counting the number of beds, a hospital must
exclude beds in Medicare-exempt departments but include neonatal
intensive care and intermediate care beds.
Once the IRB is determined, the percent add-on can be calculated.
In 1996, the formula was Percent Add-on = 1.89*[(1+IRB)0.405 – 1].
The IMEA for each case can then be calculated by multiplying this
factor by the DRG payment. This formula gave hospitals an average
add-on of 7.65% for every 10% increase in the IRB. In the Balanced
Budget Act of 1997, Congress modified the formula to cut Medicare
spending. The current average add-on is 6.5% for every 10% increase
in the IRB; by 2001, it will be 5.5%.
The Balanced Budget Act of 1997 reduced the level of the
adjustment, but maintained the unitary concept of the IMEA. In 1997,
teaching institutions received $4.6 billion from the IMEA.
Return
to AMA-YPS article, Graduate Medical Education Funding