Voters Guide

Senate Vote on Medical Privacy
H.R 3103


Medical privacy - Hidden within the massive health care reform bill approved by Congress in the stampede for an August recess was a deceptively labeled provision that further eroded the privacy rights of all Americans. The provision, known as "administrative simplification," gives government and businesses access to confidential medical information about individuals without their consent and establishes a unique health identification number for every patient, health provider, health plan and employer. The medical privacy provisions of the bill never came up for a separate vote, but the Senate approved the health care measure on a vote of 98 to 0. Earlier, the House had rejected by a vote of 198 to 226 an alternative version of the bill that would have deleted the anti-privacy provisions.

[Senators Voting Against Medical Privacy:98] [Senators Voting For Medical Privacy: 0] [Did Not Vote: 2]
The ACLU Urged a Vote For Medical Privacy
To find out how ACLU rated your Senator overall, click on his or her name


Senators Voting Against Medical Privacy

Heflin
Alabama
Shelby
Alabama
Murkowski
Alaska
Stevens
Alaska
Kyl
Arizona
McCain
Arizona
Bumpers
Arkansas
Boxer
California
Feinstein
California
Brown
Colorado
Campbell
Colorado
Dodd
Connecticut
Lieberman
Connecticut
Biden, Jr.
Delaware
Roth, Jr.
Delaware
Graham
Florida
Mack
Florida
Coverdell
Georgia
Nunn
Georgia
Akaka
Hawaii
Inouye
Hawaii
Craig
Idaho
Kempthorne
Idaho
Moseley-Braun
Illinois
Simon
Illinois
Coats
Indiana
Lugar
Indiana
Grassley
Iowa
Harkin
Iowa
Frahm
Kansas
Kassebaum
Kansas
Ford
Kentucky
McConnell
Kentucky
Breaux
Louisiana
Johnston
Louisiana
Cohen
Maine
Snowe
Maine
Mikulski
Maryland
Sarbanes
Maryland
Kennedy
Massachusetts
Kerry
Massachusetts
Abraham
Michigan
Levin
Michigan
Grams
Minnesota
Wellstone
Minnesota
Cochran
Mississippi
Lott
Mississippi
Ashcroft
Missouri
Bond
Missouri
Baucus
Montana
Burns
Montana
Exon
Nebraska
Kerrey
Nebraska
Bryan
Nevada
Reid
Nevada
Gregg
New Hampshire
Smith
New Hampshire
Bradley
New Jersey
Lautenberg
New Jersey
Bingaman
New Mexico
Domenici
New Mexico
D'Amato
New York
Moynihan
New York
Faircloth
North Carolina
Helms
North Carolina
Conrad
North Dakota
Dorgan
North Dakota
DeWine
Ohio
Glenn
Ohio
Inhofe
Oklahoma
Nickles
Oklahoma
Hatfield
Oregon
Wyden
Oregon
Santorum
Pennsylvania
Specter
Pennsylvania
Chafee
Rhode Island
Pell
Rhode Island
Hollings
South Carolina
Thurmond
South Carolina
Daschle
South Dakota
Pressler
South Dakota
Frist
Tennessee
Thompson
Tennessee
Gramm
Texas
Hutchison
Texas
Bennett
Utah
Hatch
Utah
Jeffords
Vermont
Leahy
Vermont
Robb
Virginia
Warner
Virginia
Gorton
Washington
Byrd
West Virginia
Rockefeller, IV
West Virginia
Feingold
Wisconsin
Kohl
Wisconsin
Simpson
Wyoming
Thomas
Wyoming





Senators Voting For Medical Privacy -- None


Senators Not Voting

Pryor
Arkansas
Murray
Washington




Copyright 1996, The American Civil Liberties Union