Printer friendly version of this page
SENT TO THE FULL U.S. SENATE
June 9, 2000
The Honorable Conrad Burns United States
Senate 187 Senate Dirksen Office Building Washington, DC
20510
Dear Senator Burns:
On behalf of the National Association of Manufacturers, 14,000
members companies – large, mid-sized and small – and the 18 million
people who make things in America, I urge your support for
continuing the Corporate Average Fuel Economy (CAFE) freeze in the
Department of Transportation Appropriations Act for FY 2001. The
Senate bill is tentatively scheduled for floor consideration the
week of June 12, 2000. Senator Slade Gorton (R-WA) has indicated
that he intends to offer a resolution that would instruct the Senate
conferees not to accept the CAFE freeze provisions in the House
bill. The NAM urges you to vote against this resolution.
The NAM considers this a significant issue for manufacturers and
will consider designating votes relating to the CAFE freeze as Key
Manufacturing Votes in the NAM’s Voting Record for the
106th Congress. Key Manufacturing Votes form the basis
for the NAM’s congressional ratings, which in turn determine which
members receive the NAM Award for Manufacturing Legislative
Excellence.
Since the early 1990s, the Department of Transportation
Appropriations Acts have contained restrictions on the use of funds
to increase the CAFE standards for cars (27.5 mpg) and light trucks
(20.7 mpg). For good reasons, today’s intensely competitive world is
not the time nor the place to reinvigorate a 25-year-old
command-and-control law that will dramatically reduce the ability of
manufacturers to provide American consumers and businesses with the
light trucks and cars that are right for their needs. More than
ever, just-in-time deliveries between businesses and delivery
systems in support of e-commerce require more vehicle choice, not
less.
The CAFE approach has never been a sound public policy mechanism.
Raising CAFE standards would exacerbate the flaw inherent in the
CAFE approach – "forcing" companies to make changes in their
products that consumers may not value. The NAM has consistently
opposed arbitrary government restrictions on individual choice,
particularly those that fail even a rudimentary cost-benefit test.
CAFE is an arbitrary approach that has not been successful in its
primary objectives – reducing oil imports and gasoline consumption –
but that has adversely affected American jobs and highway
safety.
More importantly, there is a better way than CAFE to improve
vehicle and fleet-fuel economy levels. Auto manufacturers worldwide
are engaged in a competitive race to develop advanced technologies
capable of dramatically increasing fuel economy. The Partnership for
a New Generation of Vehicles is one example of how this work is
being coordinated.
The NAM would greatly appreciate your support for continuing the
legislative freeze on CAFE standards in the Department of
Transportation Appropriations for FY 2001. Please vote against any
effort to remove this important provision. Thank you for your time
and consideration of these views.
Sincerely,
Michael E. Baroody Senior Vice President Policy
Communications and Public Affairs |