Farm Bureau representatives and other small business owners spoke
at a Capitol Hill press conference last week to drum up support for
a bill that would phase out the death tax. The legislation (H.R. 8),
introduced by Reps. Jennifer Dunn (R-Wash.) and John Tanner
(D-Tenn.), would reduce the estate tax rate 5 percent a year until
it is eliminated. Estate taxes in the highest bracket--55
percent--would be wiped out after 11 years.
Washington State
Farm Bureau President Steve
Appel, a third generation wheat and barley grower, said that the
death tax jeopardizes his children's ability to carry on the family
operation because the tax burden would sap the profit-making ability
from the farm.
"It's my hope that my children will become the fourth generation
to cultivate our land, but unless death tax laws are changed I'm not
sure that will happen," said Appel.
Families often have to parcel off pieces of their operations
following the death of a loved one in order to pay the resulting tax
burden. "That's not productive and it's certainly counter to the
American tradition of family-owned farms and ranches," according to
Kleckner.
Rep. Tanner agrees, saying family businesses carry far more than
a monetary value. The elimination of the death tax, he said, "is a
societal statement that we believe that saving and investing and
passing on generational family farms and small businesses is good,
is something that we ought to have as a national policy."
The death tax also forces farmers and ranchers to spend valuable
time and resources on estate planning just to keep family businesses
in the family.
"Farmers and ranchers spend countless hours preparing for their
deaths," said Kleckner. "They meet with accountants, lawyers and
more accountants and lawyers in attempts to protect their farms from
government tax collectors. These activities are time consuming,
expensive and erode the efficiency of American agriculture."
Appel said that his parents used trusts and other estate planning
tools in order to pass the farm on to him and his siblings, but even
well-laid plans are not foolproof.
"They succeeded in keeping our farm in our family, but not
without consequences for me," said Appel. "My eight brothers and
sisters are now my landlords."
Joining Appel at the press conference was Weakley County
(Tenn.) Farm
Bureau member Keith Fowler, who runs a large row crop and swine
operation with his wife, Linda, his father and his father-in-law.
The Fowlers received AFBF's Young Farmers and Ranchers Achievement
Award last January.
"Farming is tough enough without any further burdens or
obstacles," said Fowler. "The death tax is inefficient, it's unfair
and it should be eliminated."
Farm Bureau achieved limited estate tax reform during the
105th Congress when lawmakers passed the Taxpayer Relief
Act, which increases the estate tax exemption from $600,000 per
person to $1 million by 2006, with additional relief for
family-owned businesses.
While increased exemptions help, Appel maintains that elimination
of the tax is still the best option for farmers and ranchers.
"Over the years I've seen the value of my land increase to the
point that I'm not sure the estate tax exemption will be much help
when my children are ready to take over the farm," said the farm
leader. "The death tax deserves to die before more family farms and
ranches are destroyed."