Copyright 2000 The Times-Picayune Publishing Co.
The Times-Picayune
February 26, 2000 Saturday, ORLEANS
SECTION: METRO; Pg. B1
LENGTH: 421 words
HEADLINE:
ATTORNEYS SEEK
CRIMINAL JUSTICE REFORMS; GIVE PRISONERS
ACCESS TO DNA TESTS, THEY SAY
BYLINE: By Pamela Coyle
Staff writer
BODY: Some of the country's top
criminal defense attorneys said Friday that the case of a Houma man recently
exonerated after spending 19 years in prison for rape shows why states need laws
giving prisoners access to DNA testing and compensation for years wrongly taken
from them.
The National Association of Criminal Defense Attorneys,
meeting in New Orleans this week, also called for better rules governing the use
of testimony by informants and making crime labs independent from police
departments. These and other proposed reforms make up what the association
dubbed "The Innocence Agenda," a far-reaching program defense attorneys and some
lawmakers contend is needed to help correct a criminal justice system gone
astray. "All over this country, we have seen the greatest injustice -- the
innocent who have been convicted, sentenced to prison, sometimes under the
threat of death. Our system is broken," said William B. Moffitt, the
association's president. "Every time we convict an innocent person we leave a
guilty person on the street."
He was joined at a news conference by four
Louisiana legislators, noted DNA expert and lawyer Barry Scheck, who represented
former football star O.J. Simpson in his murder case, and Clyde Charles, who was
freed after DNA testing proved he did not rape a nurse almost 20 years ago.
State Rep. Reggie Dupre, D-Montegut, said he supports legislation
allowing post-conviction DNA testing and compensation for people wrongly put
behind bars.
"We need to make sure what happened to Mr. Charles never
happens again in Louisiana," Dupre said. He said he has not yet received a
response from Gov. Foster's office on whether such issues will be included in
the upcoming special session.
Reps., Leonard Lucas, Arthur Morrell, both
Democrats from New Orleans, and Kyle Green, D-Marrero, also supported the
measures. Green said Louisiana's conservative Legislature should back the
reforms because they are about fairness.
Scheck said DNA testing has
exonerated 64 other people in the United States and credited Charles and his
family with waging the battle to get the test for years.
"The door was
shut for him everywhere he went," Scheck said.
Charles, wearing a tan
three-piece suit he said was at least 20 years old, joked he was glad the
clothes still fit because he has no money to buy new ones. In prison, he
developed tuberculosis and diabetes but has been denied Social Security and
Medicaid benefits because he had not been paying into the system for the past 19
years.
GRAPHIC: 'You can't lynch a man and then ask him
if he's innocent or guilty,' Rep. Leonard Lucas, D-N.O., said Friday at a press
conference at Le Meridien Hotel. The National Association of Criminal Defense
Attorneys held the conference to unveil their ideas for
criminal justice
reforms they believe will help keep innocent people out of prison.
Barry Scheck, to the left of the podium, brought books to help explain the
problem of the unjustly jailed in America. Former Angola inmate Clyde Charles
and his sister, Lois Hill, speak at the National Association of Criminal Defense
Lawyers press conference. DNA testing proved Charles' innocence. 2 STAFF PHOTOS
BY TED JACKSON
LOAD-DATE: February 28, 2000