Wake Up and Smell the
Clear-Cut
The scenic and recreational attractions of the High Knob area,
located in Virginia within the Clinch Ranger District in Jefferson
National Forest, are some of the state's best-kept secrets. Clinch
Ranger District harbors an incredible diversity of plants and
animals, rugged mountains, and flowing streams. Unfortunately, this
type of area is not well represented in protected public lands,
especially in the High Knob region located in the far southwest
corner of the state. In the past 10 years, 80 percent of the logging
in the Clinch Ranger District has occurred in the High Knob region.
An opportunity is at hand to preserve some of the last remaining
wild places in Jefferson National Forest. Over the next two years,
the Forest Service intends to issue a draft management plan for
public comment and ultimately adopt a long-range strategy for
managing the forest. The Forest Service expects a 50 percent
increase in recreation in the South, including Virginia, by 2005,
underscoring the need to protect special wild places such as High
Knob.
WHAT'S AT STAKE
Old
Growth Forests and Critical Water Supply
If the Forest Service continues its present policies and
practices, the 57,000-acre High Knob area--with its rugged and
remote terrain, mountain streams, scenic waterfalls, popular byways,
miles of hiking trails, rich biological diversity, and old-growth
forests--will be gone or greatly diminished.
Many native plants and animals, including wildflowers, black
bears, and songbirds, are adversely affected by the lack of
protection of the large tracts of contiguous forest provided by the
High Knob area. These species depend on the remaining wildlands in
High Knob for their survival.
The Jefferson National Forest contains the headwaters of a number
of streams and rivers that nourish southwestern Virginia and provide
drinking water to area residents. The water quality of the Clinch
River, which includes a number of endangered and threatened species,
is at grave risk from several factors. One is excessive
clear-cutting. Keeping these wildlands in an undisturbed condition
will help improve the water quality and preserve world-class
fisheries.
"Few people are aware of the bounty of our national forests,"
said Michael Francis, director of The Wilderness Society's National
Forests Program. "These lands supply more than half the fresh water
used in homes and businesses. One-third of all our endangered plants
and animals depend on the forests."
THREATS
Logging Losses
The 996-acre Clear, Machine, and Burns
Creek (CMB) timber sale in High Knob is already under way. The
clear-cut operations in the High Knob region will increase the
amount of sediment in the Guest River, now on Virginia's list of
impaired waterways. According to the Forest Service's own analysis,
the CMB timber sale will dump 7.4 tons of dirt into the Guest River
over a one-year period.
A 1994-99 study of the Guest River, conducted by the Tennessee
Valley Authority, noted that the highest levels of sedimentation on
the river were recorded just below where national forest logging
activities are occurring. Increased sedimentation is a serious
concern because it raises water temperatures and degrades the
overall quality of rivers and streams, thereby threatening the
survival of marine plants and animals, as well as compromising the
drinking supply for area residents. The Guest River Group, of which
the Forest Service is a member, is attempting to clean up the river,
and the Forest Service's recommendation to increase timber sales is
exacerbating the problem.
"The
Forest Service needs to take a closer look at the effects that
timber sales in the area have on the pollution of the Guest River,"
said Detta Davis, area resident and president of The Clinch
Coalition, a newly formed grassroots organization that has asked the
Forest Service to stop logging until it has a plan that fully
protects the ecological integrity and diversity of the area. "They
are treading very close to violating the Clean Water Act."
In addition to the CMB timber sale, two others are being planned.
One is in the Bark Camp region, which stretches across High Knob and
includes two lakes and highly used recreation areas. This sale
proposes to log mature trees on 1,413 acres in the Bark Camp area.
The Bark Camp sale will build or rebuild eight miles of logging
roads in this beautiful but fragile mountaintop region. The
Wilderness Society is working with The Clinch Coalition.
Recreation Versus Logging
Recreational resources in the
area targeted for logging include scenic walking trails,
campgrounds, and scenic waterways. According to the Forest Service,
38 times more local income is generated by recreational activity on
forest land than by timbering operations, and 31 times more jobs
come from recreation than from logging.
VOICE OF THE LAND
"Since the timber cutting has occurred behind my house, we have
heard no owls at night. I have lived in this house for 25 years and
could always hear them. Now there is nothing. It is very sad that
they have destroyed the home of these animals." --Otis Ward
Otis Ward has lived on High Knob for the last 25 years. What Ward
would like most to see is this land and the animals on it preserved
for his five grandchildren.
FACTS
- The Jefferson National Forest runs through three states,
with 690,106 acres in Virginia, 18,526 acres in West
Virginia and 961 acres in Kentucky.
- Jefferson National Forest provides habitat for a variety
of species, including at least 70 species of reptiles and
amphibians, 55 species of mammals, 100 species of freshwater
fish and mussels, and 200 species of birds.
- Jefferson National Forest is located within several
major river basins, the Potomac, Roanoke, James, New, Big
Sandy, Holston, and Clinch rivers.
|
RECOMMENDATION
The Forest Service has acknowledged that many areas in the
National Forest System should be managed for conservation, not
commodities. The High Knob region of Jefferson National Forest is
the place to put these new policies to work. Future management of
Jefferson National Forest should feature three vital components:
- conservation of wildlands, roadless areas, and the remaining
high-quality fish and wildlife habitat;
- restoration of key areas damaged by decades of high-intensity
logging; and
- enhancement of compatible recreational uses and values.
PUBLIC
ACTION
Strong citizen support is needed to protect the High Knob region.
Work on the new plan has been in progress for seven years. Reduced
funding for planning may yet again delay the completion of the
Jefferson National Forest Revised Forest Plan. If this happens, it
will allow the Forest Service to continue managing Jefferson
National Forest as it has in the past--with increased logging. As
drafted, the new plan will give better protection to the forest,
including the recommendation for new wilderness areas and better
protection of riparian zones. The public can help by getting on the
mailing list to comment on the proposed revised Forest Service plan.
Take action from this site by clicking
here.
Contact:
Jefferson National Forest Plan Revision
5162 Valleypointe
Parkway
Roanoke, VA 24019
Phone: 1-888-265-0019
FOR MORE INFORMATION:
Michael Francis
TWS Director, National Forest
Program
Phone: (202) 429-2661
E-mail: michael_francis@tws.org
Shirl Parsons
Southwest Regional Grassroots
Coordinator
Phone: (404) 872-9453
E-mail: shirl_parsons@tws.org