Copyright 2000 Daily News, L.P.   
Daily News (New 
York) 
December 8, 2000, Friday SPORTS FINAL EDITION 
SECTION: NEWS; Pg. 30 
LENGTH: 420 words 
HEADLINE: 
CHILD-WELFARE REFORMS WIN THUMBS UP 
BYLINE: By BOB PORT 
DAILY NEWS STAFF WRITER 
BODY: 
A panel of experts 
declared yesterday that the city is acting in good faith to fix its child 
welfare system, relieving the mayor from having a federal judge dictate policy 
and spending on children for years to come. 
The panel's ruling came as 
part of a 1998 agreement that bound the city to take advice from experts on 
children for two years. 
The finding ends a 1995 class-action lawsuit 
against the city by child advocates on behalf of Marisol, a 4-year-old girl 
found locked in a closet and near death, despite pleas for authorities to act. 
Both sides in the case had agreed to give the panel, administered by the Anne E. 
Casey Foundation, final say over what the city should do and whether it honestly 
was doing it. 
The Administration for Children's Services has engaged in 
a "sustained, intelligent effort to change a complicated and difficult system," 
the foundation's final report said. 
It described some ACS efforts as 
being "on a scale unmatched by any other child-welfare system in the United 
States." 
Though gushing with praise, the 59-page report also warned that 
the city's "child welfare system is not yet fixed," and that troubled parents 
deserve more respect in the city's future efforts. 
"We are extremely 
pleased because this is a group of professionals who really know child welfare, 
with no political agenda," said Nicholas Scoppetta, the former prosecutor - and 
one-time foster child - enlisted by the mayor in 1996 to rebuild the city's 
child-welfare system. 
"The report is a very constructive critique of the 
system, unlike many audits, where it's a game of gotcha," he said. "It is a kind 
of vindication, I think, for ACS managers and its staff from the criticism that 
is unrelenting from some groups that just can't find it in their heart to 
acknowledge that reforms have taken place." 
The lawyer who spearheaded 
the Marisol lawsuit, Marcia Robinson-Lowry of Children's Rights Inc., also was 
pleased by the outcome. 
"A great deal that was profoundly necessary has 
either been accomplished or, more likely, planned," she said. "The kinds of 
fundamental problems that have existed in the system have been addressed with 
the prodding of the panel and, in my view, under the pressure of this lawsuit." 
Robinson said she intends to watch the city's continuing efforts like a 
hawk. 
And the case has another happy ending: Marisol, the child whose 
plight triggered the lawsuit, is now 10. "I am very happy to say," Robinson 
said, "she is in a wonderful family and is doing very well." 
LOAD-DATE: December 8, 2000