About CRLP
On the Hill
In the Courts
Worldwide
Publications
Press
Newsletter: RFN











press

in this section



Contact UsContact Us

CRLP in the NewsCRLP in the News

2001 Press Releases2001 Press Releases

2000 Press Releases2000 Press Releases

>12/21/00 A New Option for Addressing Human Rights Violations

>12/13/00 Sneha Barot Joins CRLP

>12/7/00 Texas' Failure to Cover Medicaid Abortions for Low-Income Women Found Unconstitutional

>12/5/00 International Human Rights Day - Unequal Protection for Women's Reproductive Rights

>11/30/00 Maya Manian Joins CRLP

>11/30/00 Family Planning in Guatemala Falls Woefully Short

>11/17/00 CRLP Asks U.S. Supreme Court to Strike Anti-Abortion TRAP

>11/16/00 FGM Violates Women's Human Rights

>11/14/00 Julia Zajkowski Joins CRLP

>11/14/00 Sherrie Russell Brown Joins CRLP

>10/26/00 Tzili Mor Joins CRLP

>10/25/00 CRLP Announces New Federal Legislative Counsel

>10/2400 Global Gag Rule Dropped

>10/20/00 New Report Examines East Central Europe

>10/19/00 Indiana Medicaid Victory

>10/17/00 NAPIL Fellow to Focus on Young Women's Access to Abortion

>10/10/00 Fourth Circuit Stays South Carolina Decision

>10/6/00 Coburn Mifepristone Bill

>10/4/00 Supreme Court Hears Arguments in Ferguson v. City of Charleston

>10/4/00 Statement by Priscilla Smith: Lead Counsel in Ferguson v. City of Charleston

>10/2/00 Ninth Circuit to Hear Appeal in Arizona Fetal Tissue Case

>9/29/00 Ad Campaign to Abolish Global Gag Rule

>9/28/00 FDA Approves Mifepristone

>9/28/00 Latin American and Caribbean Day for Decriminalization of Abortion

>9/20/00 Melissa Upreti Joins CRLP

>9/13/00 Rosemary Dempsey Joins CRLP as DC Director

>9/12/00 Summary Judgment Hearing in Case Against Dept. of Defense

>9/11/00 Oral Argument in Ferguson v. City of Charleston Scheduled for October 4, 2000

>9/11/00 Statement of Priscilla Smith

>8/29/00 Louisiana 'Choose Life' Plates Blocked

>8/17/00 Louisiana 'Partial Birth Abortion' Ban Found Unconstitutional

>8/16/00 Fourth Circuit Rules Against South Carolina Abortion Providers

>8/9/00 Fourth Circuit Affirms District Court Judgment Blocking Virginia

>8/2/00 Louisiana's Restrictions Against Abortion Providers Permanently Blocked by Federal Court

>7/31/00 Lawsuit Filed Against Louisiana Law Creating 'Choose Life' License Plates

>7/28/00 Fourth Circuit Issues Order Blocking Virginia 'Partial-Birth Abortion' Law

>7/13/00 Congress Votes to Restrict Reproductive Health Care Overseas

>7/10/00 West Virginia Abortion Ban Found Unconstitutional

>7/5/00 Louisiana Prison Inmate Denied Right to an Abortion

>6/30/00 Female Genital Mutilation Opposed as a Violation of International Human Rights Law

>6/29/00 Supreme Court Directs Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals to Reconsider Abortion Ban Decisions

>6/28/00 U.S. Supreme Court Finds Abortion Bans Deceptive, Unconstitutional

>6/28/00 Statement of Dr. LeRoy Carhart on the Court Ruling

>6/21/00 Romanian Government to Present Women's Rights Record Before UN

>6/20/00 Women's Advocates Urge Congress to Bag the 'Gag Rule'

>6/15/00 Lithuanian Government to Present Women's Rights Record Before UN

>6/7/00 Reproductive Rights Advocates Call on U.N. Women's Conference to Do the Right Thing

>6/7/00 State Concedes to Block Florida Abortion Ban

>6/2/00 Florida Abortion Ban Blocked by Federal Court

>6/2/00 Reproductive Rights are Central to Women's Lives - Beijing +5

>6/2/00Maternity Patients Challenge South Carolina Police-Hospital Drug Testing Scheme in U.S. Supreme Court

>6/1/00 Arizona Must Fund Medically Necessary Abortions for Low-Income Women

>5/30/00 Florida Abortion Ban to be Reviewed by Federal Judge

>5/26/00 Florida Ban on Abortion Challenged in Federal Court

>5/19/00 Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals to Hear Arguments in Louisiana Abortion Liability Law

>5/18/00 Final Arguments to be Heard in Federal Court on Indiana Abortion Restrictions

>5/14/00 Mother's Day is an Opportunity to Acknowledge the Women of the World

>5/12/00 Florida Court Recognizes Young Women’s Right to Make Abortion Decisions Without Notifying Parents

>4/28/00 Hungary's Pending Law Restricting Abortion Will Be the Topic of an Open Forum Today

>4/25/00 Future of Women's Right To Choose Abortion Before U.S. Supreme Court:
Statement of Janet Benshoof, President of CRLP


>4/25/00 Supreme Court Hears Oral Arguments:
Statement of LeRoy Carhart, MD.

>3/29/00 Court Asked to Find Nebraska Abortion Ban Unconstitutional
Statement of LeRoy Carhart, M.D.


>3/29/00 CRLP Asks Supreme Court to Declare Nebraska Abortion Ban Unconstitutional

>3/22/00 State Court Limits Enforcement of Montana Abortion Ban

>3/15/00 Women Stand Up to the Religious Right

>3/14/00 Women's Human Rights Groups Win Major Victory for Women of Peru and Latin America

>3/9/00 Federal Court Blocks Michigan’s Abortion Ban

>3/7/00 Women’s Rights Lawyer From Peru Wins Amnesty International Award

>3/6/00 Winning the Struggle for Reproductive Rights: Beijing +5 Years of Wins, Losses and Stalemates

>03/03/00- Arizona Court to Hear Medicaid-Funded Abortions Case

>3/01/00 Arizona TRAP Case Filed

>02/28/00 Nebraska asks U.S. Supreme Court to Gut the Right to Choose Abortion

>02/28/00 Supreme Court to Review CRLP Case of Pregnant Woman

>2/1/00 CRLP Challenges MI PBA in Federal Court

>01/20/00 Celebrating Choice: Reproductive Freedom Through Art, Politics and the Law

>1/14/00 Supreme Court Decides to Take CRLP's Case Challenging Nebraska's

>1/14/00 CRLP Petitions High Court to Take Wisconsin Case

1999 Press Releases1999 Press Releases

1998 Press Releases1998 Press Releases

1997 Press Releases1997 Press Releases



search


contribute
back to home
April 25, 2000

  U.S. Supreme Court Hears Oral Arguments

Statement of LeRoy Carhart, M.D.

Today I am both honored and humbled by the opportunity to bring my case before the United States Supreme Court. I am thankful to have the right to pursue justice and - in doing so - expose the lies anti-choice politicians and extremist organizations have devised to hurt women's health, overturn the right to choose, and to criminalize doctors who provide the finest possible medical care to their patients.

Seeing this challenge to Nebraska's abortion ban all the way through to the Supreme Court has been one of the most difficult but rewarding experiences of my life. I could not have persisted these past three years without the unwavering support of my wife and family, my dedicated staff, and fellow abortion providers. I am indebted to Simon Heller and Janet Benshoof, my attorneys and advocates from the Center for Reproductive Law and Policy -- my dream team. They have provided me the best legal representation possible. And, they have given me hope that, in this country, in America, we do not make criminals out of doctors because they provide the best care possible to women who need abortions.

I have said before that I never dreamed I would be involved in a case before the Supreme Court. But I stand here today knowing I have done the right thing. Nebraska's abortion ban is not about "late" abortions nor is it limited to any particular procedure. The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists and other medical groups that have signed on in support of my case agree that the vaguely worded law applies to all stages of pregnancy. That's why this case and these bans are so insidious-they are deceptive attempts to overturn the right to choose whether or not to have a safe and legal abortion.

Challenging this extreme ban was, for my family, and me, an act of citizenship and patriotism. This ban violates the Constitution. This ban threatens the health of women. This ban also violates the very essence of what it is to be American. In this country, in America, the government cannot intervene in the most personal and private decisions of families for the purpose of pursuing an extremist political agenda. In this country, politicians are not supposed to be able to tell you when and how often to bear children. In this country, politicians should not be able to threaten the lives of women to gain political advantage or an electoral office.

I was a young physician in the years before Roe v. Wade made abortion legal. I saw women who came to the hospital dying or close to death and it made a lasting impression on me. Thousands of women each year died needlessly and others were left sterile because they could not receive critical medical care. I learned then that women will do whatever they have to do - whether legal or not - to end a crisis pregnancy. The costs of illegal abortions to women's lives, to their families, and to the American society is too high. There must be a firm moral, medical, and political commitment to prevent a return to the days when we sacrificed women.

The future of the right to choose abortion is now in the hands of the Supreme Court. No matter what the Court decides, I will remain grateful that I live in a country that allows me - just an average citizen from Nebraska - to defend my convictions. I am proud that I served in the armed forces of the United States, the freest land in the world. I am proud that I have provided my patients with the best medical care this country has to offer. I feel equally privileged to have the opportunity to stand before the Supreme Court as a representative of the millions of Americans who believe that women's health and rights must never be oppressed by or sacrificed to a zealous, violent faction intent on undermining the Constitution and destroying what is best about our country - the right of individuals to achieve their dreams and live their lives in freedom.



















































































































































































































































About CRLP
On the Hill
In the Courts
Worldwide
Publications
Press
Newsletter: RFN