The Center for Reproductive Law and Policy
(CRLP), which represents abortion providers in Florida, will present
arguments before U.S. District Judge Joan A. Lenard on why Florida's
"partial-birth abortion" ban, signed into law last Thursday by Governor
Bush, is detrimental to women's health and should therefore be blocked
from enforcement.
CRLP filed for an emergency order to block the ban from taking effect
on Friday. It was denied by sitting federal judge Ursula Ungaro-Benages,
who ordered both parties-CRLP and the state-to attend the Wednesday
hearing to determine whether the ban would continue to be enforced.
CRLP asserts that the language in the law is so broad that it would
prohibit abortion early in pregnancy - beginning as early as 11 weeks of
pregnancy -- and subject doctors to criminal prosecution for providing the
safest medical care. Additionally, the ban fails to contain adequate
exceptions to protect women's life and health.
U.S. District Judge Donald L. Graham struck down a similar Florida law
in 1998, criticizing its inadequate protection for the health and life of
the woman. The penalties against physicians are harsher in the current law
in comparison to the 1998 version, having been increased from third to
second degree felony charges, subject to $10,000 fines and up to fifteen
years in prison.
Currently the U.S. Supreme Court is considering the constitutionality
of Nebraska's "partial-birth abortion" ban. CRLP represents Dr. Carhart,
the physician who challenged the Nebraska law. At stake is the ability of
states to restrict abortion before fetal viability without regard for
women's health and safety. The Supreme Court decision, which is expected
by early July, will determine whether Florida's ban is constitutional.
Plaintiffs in A Choice for Women v. Butterworth, the challenge
to Florida's abortion ban, include A Choice for Women, Edward R. Watson,
M.D., Presidential Women's Center, Michael Benjamin, M.D., and Bella Doe.
They are represented by Janet Crepps and Suzanne Novak of the Center for
Reproductive Law and Policy, and local cooperating counsel Louis M. Silber
of West Palm Beach and Charlene Carres of Tallahassee.
For more information on abortion bans, including CRLP's case in the
U.S. Supreme Court on Nebraska's abortion ban, see our special report.