Copyright 2002 The Washington Post
The
Washington Post
May 16, 2002, Thursday, Final Edition
SECTION: A SECTION; Pg. A18
LENGTH: 1064 words
HEADLINE:
Hill Group Urges End To
Sanctions on
Cuba;
Bush Plans to Keep Policy in Place
BYLINE: Peter Slevin
and Karen DeYoung, Washington Post Staff Writers
BODY:
Forty members of Congress called yesterday for unrestricted
U.S. travel and increased trade with
Cuba as the first steps in
an overhaul of a decades-old foreign policy that has failed to topple Cuban
President Fidel Castro or deliver democracy to the island.
Reflecting
growing congressional dissatisfaction with the hard-line U.S. approach toward
Cuba, the appeal from 20 Republicans and 20 Democrats came one
day after former president Jimmy Carter delivered a speech in Havana urging
closer relations between
Cuba and the United States, and the
lifting of travel restrictions and the economic embargo.
The Bush
administration quickly asserted that the embargo and travel restrictions must
remain as long as Castro continues to deny civil liberties to
Cuba's 11 million citizens. President Bush intends to outline
his policy Monday, emphasizing the idea of being tough with the Cuban government
and open toward Cuban citizens. "President Carter speaks his mind, and he spoke
his mind with respect to our policy, which he would like to see change but which
is not going to change," Secretary of State Colin L. Powell told reporters on
his way home from a NATO summit in Iceland. "I think the president will
reinforce that when he gives his speech. And I'm sure it will be a speech,
though, that also offers hope and promise to the Cuban people."
A debate
over U.S. policy toward
Cuba is brewing at a moment when
Congress and the Bush administration are moving in separate directions.
Administration policy, developed with the help of conservative Cuban American
appointees, aims to enforce Castro's economic isolation and bolster
pro-democracy forces, while congressional majorities have repeatedly voted to go
further by increasing U.S. trade and travel.
The
Cuba
Working Group is a new caucus created this year to push for changes in policies
followed by Republican and Democratic administrations. The range of districts
and re[acute]sume[acute]s of its members illustrates the evaporation of the
ideological cohesion that helped define U.S. policy during the Cold War, when
Castro's communist government aligned itself with the Soviet Union.
The
group's nine-point plan issued yesterday is meant as a series of incremental
steps. It does not call for direct U.S. investment, diplomatic relations or
foreign aid. The list included an appeal for normal exports of U.S. food and
medicine; an end to limits on money sent by Cuban Americans to relatives in
Cuba; and the sunset next year of the Helms-Burton Act, which
tightened the U.S. embargo in 1996.
The group also recommended increased
"security cooperation" between the two governments; an end to TV Marti, the
U.S.-sponsored television network that costs more than $ 20 million a year but
is rarely seen in
Cuba; and the creation of scholarship
programs to increase communication between Cubans and Americans.
In
remarks to reporters yesterday, members of the working group asked why the
administration enforces tougher trade rules against
Cuba than
against Iraq or China. They noted that the United States on Tuesday sponsored a
successful U.N. resolution permitting virtually unrestricted trade in civilian
goods with Iraq and that the administration pursues free trade with China
despite its one-party state and long record of human rights abuses.
The
embargo opponents also noted that exposure to Western ideas through trade and
travel influenced the pro-democracy movements that swept aside the communist
governments of Central Europe in 1989 and contributed to the collapse of the
Soviet empire. They pointed to arguments by successive occupants of the White
House that economic openings in China and Russia will lead to increased
political freedoms.
"Adopt a policy of engagement. It has proven
successful elsewhere in the world," said Rep. William D. Delahunt (D-Mass.), who
worked with Rep. Jeff Flake (R-Ariz.) to assemble the group of representatives.
The group's first goal is overturning the travel ban.
"It's way past
due. The reasons for putting it into place are far gone by already," said
Marilyn Meiser, 75, a retired schoolteacher who was fined $ 1,000 for taking a
bicycle trip in rural
Cuba. Reached in Milton, Wis., she said
she had not known she was breaking the law.
Carter's call for the
lifting of U.S.
sanctions and the public appeal by the
lawmakers put the administration on the defensive. Administration officials made
clear, however, that the embargo policy will not change.
Bush also will
remain firm on the travel policy, which led to 766 Americans being cited last
year, up from 188 in 2000, officials said. One condition the administration
expects to enforce is the requirement that pilots of pleasure boats traveling to
Cuba obtain permission from the U.S. government.
"I
wouldn't expect any dramatic departures from what the president and the
secretary have said publicly about
Cuba on numerous occasions,"
a State Department official said.
The president intends to support
measures designed to "expand the flow and the breadth of information available
to the Cuban people," the official said. That includes a revamping of the
programming of Radio Marti, the Miami-based U.S. government radio station that
is the sister network to TV Marti, and an increased distribution of radios by
U.S. diplomats in Havana.
"It's important for information to be made
available about the possibilities and the alternatives that are out there," said
the official, who described the effort as "a continuation and a strengthening of
the outreach program."
During the 2000 presidential campaign and his
speech on Cuban Independence Day a year ago, Bush promised tougher measures
against Castro's government, including increased aid to dissidents inside
Cuba, strengthened U.S. government broadcasting to the island,
and a tightened travel ban.
Proponents of such measures contend the
administration has done too little in these areas over the past year. Hopes
among some Cuban Americans that the administration would change the amount and
type of U.S.-government aid provided to dissidents -- allowing direct cash
payments in addition to office and information supplies -- have gone
unfulfilled. TV Marti's weak signal is jammed by Castro, and some supporters
favor broadcasts from the U.S. military base at Guantanamo Bay,
Cuba. LOAD-DATE: May 16, 2002