NCRC Summary of Major CRA & Fair Lending
BillsBelow is a summary of current CRA and fair lending
bills. Please take a moment to read through the document and see if your
member of Congress is co-sponsoring any of the bills. If not, please
contact your member of Congress, and ask him or her to co-sponsor.
CRA Modernization Act of 2001
What: Representatives
Gutierrez (D-IL) and Barrett (D-WI) and 32 other Representatives have
sponsored the Community Reinvestment Modernization Act of 2001, H.R. 865.
This legislation will allow the Community Reinvestment Act to keep pace
with the tremendous changes taking place in the financial industry by
extending CRA to all lending affiliates of financial holding companies.
Mortgage companies, insurance agents and other non-traditional lending
affiliates of holding companies would be required to comply with CRA.
Lenders would be penalized on CRA exams for making predatory loans. In
addition, the bill would extend CRA-like requirements to insurance
companies and securities firms. Insurance companies would be required to
publicly disclose data on the race, income and gender of their customers.
Mergers between depository and non-depository institutions would be
subject to public comment periods with regulatory agency decisions based
on CRA, fair lending, safety and soundness and anti-trust factors.
Why: The Department of Treasury and Federal Reserve Board
economists have found that CRA, fair lending laws, and CRA agreements
increase the number of loans to minority and low- and moderate-income
communities. CRA needs to be updated to take into account the tremendous
changes in the financial industry if it is to be as successful in the
first decade of the 21st century as it was in the
1990’s.
Anti-Predatory Lending Bills
What: Senators
Schumer (D-NY) and Sarbanes (D-MD) and Representatives LaFalce (D-NY) and
Schakowsky (D-IL) introduced anti-predatory bills last year that would
prohibit abusive loan terms and conditions on high interest-rate loans.
These terms include single premium credit insurance, large prepayment
penalties, high balloon payments, and mandatory arbitration. The bills
also prohibit lending without regard of the borrower ability to repay and
flipping, or the repeated refinancing of loans tacking on higher fees
and/or increasing interest rates. The Schakowsky bill mandates the Annual
Percentage Rate in HMDA (Home Mortgage Disclosure Act) data (the CRA
modernization bill likewise includes fees and interest rates in HMDA).
Rep. LaFalce re-introduced his anti-predatory bill as H.R. 1051. The other
bills from last year will be re-introduced shortly.
NCRC also
supports another LaFalce bill, HR 1053 or the Equal Credit Enhancement and
Neighborhood Preservation Act. The bill requires lenders to offer the most
favorable terms possible to borrowers based on their credit history. It
also makes it illegal to steer borrowers on the basis of their race,
gender, or age to high cost loans with onerous terms. Finally, the bill
mandates the disclosure of the Annual Percentage Rate, debt-to-income,
loan-to-value, and other critical information in HMDA data that will make
it possible for neighborhoods to identify which lenders are responsible,
and which lenders are out to gouge borrowers. We also strongly back
LaFalce bill H.R. 1055 that would ban the involvement of federally insured
depository institutions in payday lending. Payday lending, just like
predatory lending, is a wealth-stripping scourge.
Why: Predatory
lending is threatening the reinvestment gains made possible by CRA and the
nation’s fair lending laws. Community groups around the country share
horror stories of predatory lenders victimizing minorities, senior
citizens, and low- and moderate-income homeowners. The Department of
Housing and Urban Development documents that African-American
neighborhoods are five times more likely to receive subprime refinance
loans than white neighborhoods. The Research Institute for Housing America
finds that minorities are more likely to receive subprime loans than
whites even after controlling for credit risk factors. Additional consumer
and community protections are needed to make sure that subprime lending is
free of price discrimination and predatory terms and
conditions.
Data Disclosure Bills
What: Rep. McGovern
(D-MA) will introduce a bill shortly to require the race and gender of
small business borrowers as part of the CRA small business data. Such a
requirement is also part of the CRA modernization bill. In addition, the
Schakowsky anti-predatory bill and the CRA modernization bill contain
enhancements to HMDA data to include the APR as well as loan
fees.
Why: Data disclosure results in increases in loans to
traditionally underserved populations. This occurred when Congress
improved HMDA data in 1990 to include the race, gender, and income of
borrowers. It is now time to do the same for the CRA small business data.
The disclosure of interest rates and fees in HMDA data will help community
groups and regulatory agencies identify which lenders are making high
interest rate loans with onerous terms and conditions.
Remove
Harmful Provisions of the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act of 1999
NCRC
believes that we must restore the two-year CRA exam review for small
banks. CRA sunshine disclosure requirements must be repealed or
significantly scaled back. For more details, see the NCRC Briefing Paper
on CRA and the Fair Lending Laws.
Co-Sponsors of CRA
Modernization Act of 2001
The CRA Modernization Act of 2001
(H.R. 865), introduced by Congressmen Barrett and Gutierrez, now has 34
co-sponsors! Current Co-sponsors include:
Rep Acevedo-Vila,
Anibal (D-PR)
Rep Baldwin, Tammy (D-WI)
Rep Blagojevich, Rod R.
(D-IL)
Rep Bonior, David E. (D-MI)
Rep Borski, Robert A.
(D-PA)
Rep Brown, Corrine (D-FL)
Rep Brown, Sherrod (D-OH)
Rep
Capuano, Michael E. (D-MA)
Rep Clay, Wm. Lacy (D-MO)
Rep Davis,
Danny K. (D--IL)
Rep Davis, Susan A. (D-CA)
Rep Doyle, Michael F.
(D-PA)
Rep Engel, Eliot L. (D-NY)
Rep Filner, Bob (D-CA)
Rep
Frank, Barney (D-MA)
Rep Frost, Martin (D-TX)
Rep Gutierrez, Luis V.
(D-IL)
Rep Hinchey, Maurice D. (D-NY)
Rep Hooley, Darlene
(D-OR)
Rep Jones, Stephanie Tubbs (D-OH)
Rep Kucinich, Dennis J.
(D-OH)
Rep Lee, Barbara (D-CA)
Rep Lipinski, William O.
(D-IL)
Rep McDermott, Jim (D-WA)
Rep McGovern, James P.
(D-MA)
Rep McKinney, Cynthia A. (D-GA)
Rep Meek, Carrie P.
(D-FL)
Rep Norton, Eleanor Holmes (D-DC)
Rep Pastor, Ed
(D-AZ)
Rep Roybal-Allard, Lucille (D-CA)
Rep Rush, Bobby L.
(D-IL)
Rep Sanders, Bernard (I-VT)
Rep Towns, Edolphus (D-NY)
Rep Waxman, Henry A. (D-CA)
Anti-Predatory
Lending
The fourteen current co-sponsors of Rep. LaFalce's
Predatory Lending Consumer Protection Act (H.R. 1051)
include:
Rep Capuano, Michael E.(D-MA)
Rep. Carson, Julia
(D-IN)
Rep. Clay, Wm. Lacy (D-MO)
Rep. Davis, Danny (D-IL)
Rep
Engel, Eliot L.(D-NY)
Rep Gutierrez, Luis V. (D-IL)
Rep Hinchey,
Maurice D. (D-NY)
Rep Jones, Stephanie Tubbs (D-OH)
Rep Kanjorski,
Paul E. (D-PA)
Rep Lee, Barbara (D-CA)
Rep Maloney, Carolyn B.
(D-NY)
Rep Miller, George (D-CA)
Rep Rush, Bobby L (D-IL)
Rep
Schakowsky, Janice D. (D-IL)
Congressman LaFalce has introduced two
other significant bills deserving support.
The Equal Credit
Enhancement and Neighborhood Protection Act (H.R. 1053) expands
federal fair lending protections to combat racial steering and reverse
redlining practices in subprime credit and enhances HMDA data reporting on
credit availability and cost in poor and minority neighborhoods. The ten
current co-sponsors include:
Rep Capuano, Michael E.(D-MA)
Rep
Clay, Wm. Lacy (D-MO)
Rep. Davis, Danny (D-IL)
Rep Gutierrez, Luis
V. (D-IL)
Rep Hinchey, Maurice D. (D-NY)
Rep Jones, Stephanie Tubbs
(D-OH)
Rep Lee, Barbara (D-CA)
Rep Miller, George (D-CA)
Rep
Rush, Bobby, L (D-IL)
Rep Schakowsky, Janice D. (D-IL)
The
Payday Loan Consumer Protection Act (H.R. 1055) prohibits federally
regulated institutions from participating in payday lending, prohibits use
of instruments drawn on federally-insured accounts as collateral for
payday loans, and applies Truth in Lending Act disclosure protections to
payday loans. There are currently twelve co-sponsors:
Rep Capuano,
Michael E.(D-MA)
Rep Clay, Wm. Lacy (D-MO)
Rep. Davis, Danny
(D-IL)
Rep Gutierrez, Luis V. (D-IL)
Rep Hinchey, Maurice D.
(D-NY)
Rep Jones, Stephanie Tubbs (D-OH)
Rep Kanjorski, Paul E.
(D-PA)
Rep Lee, Barbara (D-CA)
Rep Maloney, Carolyn B. (D-NY)
Rep
Miller, George (D-CA)
Rep Rush, Bobby L (D-IL)
Rep Schakowsky,
Janice D. (D-IL)
The full text of the bills, their status, and up to date lists
of co-sponsors can be obtained on the internet at thomas.loc.gov