Bishops' Aide Urges Congress to
Approve
Weldon/Stupak Human Cloning Ban,
Defeat Greenwood
Substitute
WASHINGTON (July 31, 2001) -- Msgr. William P. Fay, General
Secretary of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, urged Congress
to approve without delay the Weldon/Stupak Human Cloning Prohibition Act. In a
July 31 letter to Congress, Msgr. Fay called for defeat of a substitute bill
by Congressman Greenwood that would provide federal approval for the creation
and destruction of cloned human embryos.
The Human Cloning Prohibition
Act was approved 18-to-11 by the House Judiciary Committee with a vote by the
full House expected shortly.
Citing the urgency of the situation, Msgr.
Fay noted that some researchers have already announced they are trying to
produce a live-born child by cloning, despite an overwhelming scientific
consensus that about 99% of new humans created by this method would die before
birth, and the rare survivor would suffer from massive medical problems. The
Weldon/Stupak bill would ban the use of somatic cell nuclear transfer to
create a new organism of the human species.
The bill would have no
effect on in vitro fertilization or any other reproductive technology in
current use, but deals only with cases of asexual reproduction which do not
involve fertilization of eggs by sperm. The bill explicitly exempts any use of
cloning technology to produce animals, plants, DNA, tissues, or cells other
than human embryos (including stem cells which are not themselves human
embryos).
In the letter, Msgr. Fay took issue with proponents of
cloning who argue that the bill interferes with a procedure that is essential
to stem cell research. He noted that a new report by the National Institutes
of Health cites cloning as one way to prevent rejection of embryonic stem
cells as foreign tissue, but cites other approaches as well--and expresses
great uncertainty as to whether these cells will provoke a significant immune
reaction even without such manipulations.
He also noted that the
scientific journal Nature reported recently that the idea of using embryo
cloning to provide tailor-made stem cells is "falling from favour," that "many
experts do not now expect therapeutic cloning to have a large clinical
impact."
Msgr. Fay said those biotechnology companies which still favor
human cloning for research purposes support the Greenwood bill because it
explicitly authorizes and even licenses laboratories to pursue research
designed to refine the cloning process, and in ten years automatically drops
all legal barriers to the use of cloned embryos to initiate a pregnancy. In
the meantime, the Greenwood proposal would bar states from enacting any
genuine ban on human cloning within their own jurisdictions.
"The
framers of the Weldon/Stupak bill understand that once a society allows
experimental human cloning in the laboratory, attempts to initiate pregnancies
and to create live-born children by cloning are inevitable," Msgr. Fay wrote.
"I therefore urge you to defeat the Greenwood substitute and to approve the
Weldon/Stupak ban on human cloning without delay."
Full
text of the
letter.
__________________________________
Office of Communications
United States Conference of
Catholic Bishops
3211 4th Street, N.E., Washington, DC 20017-1194 (202)
541-3000
June 03, 2003 United States Conference
of Catholic Bishops