Legislative Update
October 24, 2002
Download in printable PDF format.
Lame Duck Session Planned
Facing pressure from Senators on both sides of the aisle,
Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle last week agreed to recess
the Senate until after the elections. The House had previously
agreed to recess for the elections. Both Houses of Congress
will be in pro forma session, subject to the call of
the Chair, until November 12, when they plan to return for a
lame-duck session.
Consequently, the House and Senate last week approved a new
continuing resolution (CR), which provides funding at the FY
2002 level for most federal programs including the federal
transit program through November 22.
In both the House and Senate, the FY 2003 Transportation
and Related Agencies Appropriations bills that provide funding
for the federal transit program have been approved by the
respective Appropriations Committees, but not yet considered
by the full House or Senate. (See discussion below of House
Committee action on the bill.) Under the normal process, each
House votes on separate bills approved by its own
Appropriations Committee, and the separate bills are then
merged into a compromise House/Senate conference agreement
that must again be approved by each House of Congress before
being sent to the President and signed into law.
Until the regular FY 2003 transportation appropriations
bill is passed, transit programs are funded at the FY 2002
level under the CR. However, the FTA is not expected to
distribute transit funds under the short-term CR, but rather
will await Congress return after the elections when a bill or
longer term CR is likely to be enacted.
Political Gridlock Dominates
Agenda
With very slim majorities by opposing parties in the House
and Senate, a flagging economy and mid-term elections that
could affect those majorities, Congress has struggled to
achieve legislative consensus throughout the past year.
At this stage, Congress has been able to pass only two of
the 13 regular appropriations bills. It has not been able to
agree on a budget resolution, creation of a Department of
Homeland Security, a comprehensive energy policy, election
reform, or terrorism insurance.
House Appropriations Committee Passes DOT
Appropriations Bill; Federal Transit Program to Receive $7.226
Billion
House Committee Approves Transit Funding
at Guaranteed Level
The House Appropriations Committee approved the FY 2003
Department of Transportation Appropriations bill October 1.
The bill funds the federal transit program at $7.226 billion,
the guaranteed amount under the Transportation Equity Act for
the 21st Century (TEA 21). The Senate version,
approved by the full Senate Appropriations Committee in July,
provides $100 million more than the guaranteed funding, with
that $100 million directed to the new starts program.
Program |
FY 2002 Appropriations (Millions) |
FY 2003 Senate Committee (Millions) |
FY 2003 House Committee (Millions) |
Capital Investment (a) |
2,841.0 |
3,136.0 |
3,036.0 |
New Starts |
1,136.4 |
1,314.4 |
1,214.4 |
Fixed-Guideway Modernization |
1,136.4 |
1,214.4 |
1,214.4 |
Bus and Bus Capital (a) |
568.2 |
607.2 |
607.2 |
Formula Funds (b) |
3,592.0 |
3,839.0 |
3,839.0 |
Urbanized Area |
3,216.0 |
3,445.9 |
3,428.7 |
Rural |
224.6 |
240.6 |
239.4 |
Elderly and Disabled Persons |
84.6 |
90.7 |
90.7 |
Clean Fuels (b) |
50.0 |
50.0 |
50.0 |
Paralympic Games |
5.0 |
--- |
--- |
Alaska Railroad |
4.8 |
4.8 |
4.8 |
Over-the-Road Accessibility |
7.0 |
7.0 |
7.0 |
Oversight (c) |
--- |
--- |
18.4 |
Job Access and Reverse Commute |
125.0 |
150.0 |
150.0 |
Planning and Research |
116.0 |
122.0 |
122.0 |
University Transportation Centers |
6.0 |
6.0 |
6.0 |
FTA Administration |
67.0 |
73.0 |
73.0 |
TOTAL |
6,747.0 |
7,326.0 |
7,226.0 |
-
Does not include $50 million transferred from "Formula
Clean Fuels" to "Bus and Bus Capital."
-
Includes $50 million authorized for "Formula Clean Fuels"
and transferred to "Bus and Bus Capital."
- Oversight funds are included in the Urbanized Area and
Rural formula programs in FY 2002 Appropriations and
FY 2003 Senate Committee amounts.
The Committee rejected an amendment offered by
Representative Sabo that would have increased Amtrak funding
to the $1.2 billion Amtrak says it needs to continue operating
through FY 2003. The Administration requested $521 million for
Amtrak while the Senate Committee-approved bill funds Amtrak
at $1.2 billion. The House bill includes $762 million for
Amtrak.
The Committee did approve an amendment offered by
Subcommittee Chairman Hal Rogers that strikes language in the
committee draft that would have eliminated federal funding, as
of July 1, 2003, on any Amtrak long-distance route where the
per passenger per trip loss exceeded $200. This language was
replaced with a provision that limits federal assistance for
Amtrak's long distance network of routes to $150 million.
The House bill includes amended language that would
authorize the federal Surface Transportation Board (STB) to
direct the continuation of commuter rail service in the event
of a cessation in services provided by Amtrak. The bill also
provides $8 million for a grant to a public body to
demonstrate the use of a compliant diesel multiple units (DMU)
rail car in daily revenue service in calendar year 2003. Funds
are to be matched by non-federal sources.
On a party-line vote, the Committee rejected an amendment
to add more than $4 billion to the $27.7 billion recommended
by the Committee for highway spending in FY 2003. Subcommittee
Chairman Rogers stated that the House bill simply could not
afford the additional funding. The Senate bill includes
$31.8 billion for highways.
A list of earmarks for both the House and Senate is posted
on APTA's website at http://www.apta.com/. Click on
Government Affairs; then Appropriations for the
October 17, 2002 listing.
Other Legislative Updates
Congress Votes to Restore Short-Term
Highway Funding within CR
As part of the CR, and after ongoing negotiations, Congress
passed a provision designed to ensure that, for the duration
of the CR, Federal-aid highway programs will be sustained at a
funding rate based on the amount of money the programs
received last year--$31.8 billion, but with a cap on
obligations of $27.7 billion. This effort was necessary
because a RABA shortfall has lowered highway funding levels,
and the Administration's budget proposed to fund the highway
program at levels significantly lower than the FY 2002
level.
Because of confusion about the provision - whether the
$31.8 billion or $27.7 billion level applied - OMB was asked
to provide its opinion on the issue. A letter from OMB
Director Mitch Daniels concludes that the effect of the
provision is to provide highway funding at the same level as
that enacted in FY 2002 - that is, $31.8 billion, which will
apply until the final FY 2003 funding level is determined in
the context of the House, Senate and Administration
negotiations of the FY 2003 Transportation Appropriations
bill.
Bill for Transit Systems Affected by
Census
On October 1, the President signed into law a bill (P.L.
107-232) that permits transit systems in UZAs that moved from
under 200,000 in population to over 200,000 to continue using
federal funds for operating expenses at FY 2002 levels. APTA
urged both the House Transportation and Infrastructure
Committee and the Senate Banking Committee to support this
legislation. The law applies only to FY 2003 funds.
Expedite Bill Introduced
Chairman Don Young of the House Transportation and
Infrastructure Committee introduced the "Expediting Project
Delivery to Improve Transportation and the Environment Act"
(H.R. 5455). The bill would streamline the federal review of
projects and make a number of changes to federal transit law
that have been sought by APTA. According to Chairman Youngs
staff, the bill is a first step in addressing delays in
transit and highway projects, and will be further considered
next year.
APTAs President Bill Millar testified on the measure before
the Transportation and Infrastructure Subcommittee on Highways
and Transit on Tuesday, October 8. The testimony is posted on
APTA's website at http://www.apta.com/. Click on
Government Affairs; Current APTA Positions; then
Testimony.
TANF Reauthorization
Regarding reauthorization of Temporary Assistance for Needy
Families (TANF) legislation, the Senate Finance Committee
marked up its version, "The Work, Opportunity, and
Responsibility for Kids (WORK) Act" of 2002 on June 25.
Provisions in the Senate bill would improve coordination
between health and human service providers and transportation
agencies and reduce requirements that inhibit flexibility,
innovation, and successful expansion of transportation options
for low-income people. The House passed its version, the
Personal Responsibility, Work and Family Promotion Act of
2002, on May 16. The CR extends TANF reauthorization through
December 30, 2002. Congress is unlikely to complete work on
TANF reauthorization during the lame duck session, and APTA
will to press for provisions favorable to transit when TANF
reauthorization is taken up next year.
Rail Update
Highway funding is not the only issue that House and Senate
appropriators will have to work out on a final Transportation
Appropriations bill, even if it is done as part of a larger
omnibus-spending bill. Differences between the House and
Senate versions of the Federal Railroad Administrations budget
involve Amtrak funding levels. The House includes $762 million
for Amtrak; the Senate provides $1.2 billion. Amtrak President
David Gunn has indicated that Amtrak will need a $1.2 billion
appropriation in FY 2003 to continue service. The current CR
that expires on November 22 will fund Amtrak at a level of $1
billion until such time as a new appropriations bill is
enacted.
Other differences between Senate and House versions of the
bill include language in the House bill that would authorize
the federal Surface Transportation Board (STB) to direct the
continuation of commuter rail service in the event of a
cessation in services provided by Amtrak. The bill also
provides $8 million for a grant to a public body to
demonstrate the use of a compliant diesel multiple units (DMU)
rail car in daily revenue service in calendar year 2003. Funds
are to be matched by non-federal sources.
Of Interest: Recent Hearings
House Subcommittee on Highways and
TransitConditions and Performance Report
The House Subcommittee on Highways and Transit held a
hearing on September 26 on the "Status of the Nations Highway
and Transit Systems: Capital and Maintenance Needs." The
Secretary of Transportation submits to Congress every two
years a report that describes "estimates of the future
highway, bridge and transit needs" known as the Conditions and
Performance Report. The purpose of the hearing was to have
FHWA, FTA, and GAO testify on the report. The Administration
is still working on the report and has not released the final
version.
Robert Jamison, Deputy Administrator of the FTA, testified
on the findings of the 2002 report, which has not yet been
formally released. He stated that in estimating transit's
long-term investment requirements, $14.84 billion per year is
needed to maintain transit. The cost to improve transit is
estimated at $20.62 billion per year according to the
report. FTA Administrator Dorn also discussed transit needs at
a Senate Banking Committee hearing (see below).
Senate Banking CommitteeTransit
Needs
The Senate Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs Committee
held a hearing on October 8 on transit needs and how those
needs may be addressed in next years development of
legislation reauthorizing programs currently funded under TEA
21. Senator Paul Sarbanes (D-MD), Chairman of the Committee,
noted that the increased investment provided under TEA 21 had
paid off in terms of increased ridership, service, and quality
of life improvements.
Witnesses before the committee included FTA Administrator
Jenna Dorn, Mayor Patrick McCrory of Charlotte, N.C., Eric
Rodriquez of the National Council of La Raza, David Winstead
on behalf of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, Wendell Cox on
behalf of the Heritage Foundation, and Roy Kienitz from the
Maryland Department of Planning. Senators Jack Reed (D-RI),
Jon Corzine (D-NJ), and Thomas Carper (D-DE) all participated
in the hearing.
The Administrator acknowledged that the Bush Administration
would propose to reduce the federal match on new start
projects from the current level of 80% to 50%. The
Administrator also said that guaranteed funding had been one
of the key successes of TEA 21 and that the Administration
would seek to retain guarantees. FTA Administrator Dorn was
questioned on the pending DOT Conditions and Performance
Report. Ms. Dorn stated that the transit needs assessment to
improve transit was $20.62 billion a year but noted that the
needs assessment for transit is based on a ridership growth
rate of 1.6% annually, despite significant growth over the
past six years, and did not account for costs associated with
increased security needs. Note that adjusting the FTA transit
needs improvement analysis for 2003 dollars, and including
annual ridership estimates of 4.5 percent, results in a $32.6
billion a year needs amount. Further, the recently issued
AASHTO Bottom Line Report quantifies the annual need to
improve transit at $43.9 billion. This hearing may be
viewed at the Senate Banking Committee's website,
http:/banking.senate.gov/.
APTA Info
Reauthorization Task Force Proposal
Approved
At APTAs Annual Meeting and Expo in Las Vegas on September
22, the Legislative Committee and Board of Directors
unanimously approved the Reauthorization Task Forces TEA 21
reauthorization recommendations. The proposals recommend that
the federal transit program grow from $7.2 billion in
FY 2003 to $14.3 billion over the six-year life of the
next reauthorization bill. The proposals also support
maintaining the funding guarantee and contain some forty
proposals to improve program delivery. A colorful brochure
summarizing the APTA proposal is now available.
APTA Legislative Committee to Meet
December 6
APTAs Legislative Committee is scheduled to meet in
Washington, D.C. on Friday, December 6. While the agenda has
not yet been finalized, the Committee will likely receive a
report from the Reauthorization Task Force Working Group on
Revenue, Finance, and Program Support, which is chaired by
Task Force Co-Chair Alan Wulkan; review the results of
congressional elections; and strategize on the upcoming
reauthorization of TEA 21 and other legislative issues in the
year ahead. The Working Group on Revenue, Finance, and Program
Support has been meeting regularly since September via
conference call to develop options for financing APTAs
Reauthorization Proposal.
For further information, contact Tom Yedinak at
(202) 496-4865 or tyedinak@apta.com.