National Trust for Historic Preservation - Click here to return to the Home Page

Join the National
Trust
Donate to the
National Trust
Preservation Week
National Preservation
Awards
Volunteer
Opportunities
Corporate Partners
State and Local
Partnerships
Issues and Initiatives
Advocate Better
Policies
Legislative Action
Center
Preservation Advocate
News
Join the National Trust
Help from the National Trust
The National Trust in Your State
Contact the National Trust
National Trust Home Page

 


Advocate Better Policies

PRESERVATION ADVOCATE NEWS

July 19, 2002, Vol. 6, Issue 5

horizontal line

IN THIS ISSUE

Feature Stories

Legislative Updates

Announcements

Feature Stories

FY'03 Interior Appropriations Bill Marked Up in House and Senate: House-Passed Funding Levels for Historic Preservation at Odds with Senate Bill

The House Subcommittee on Interior Appropriations marked up the FY'03 Interior spending bill on June 25 and unanimously approved a $9.5 million increase for the Historic Preservation Fund (HPF) over the President's budget, raising the HPF's total funding to $76.5 million. The House bill provides $40 million for the States, $4 million for the tribes, $30 million for the Save America's Treasures Fund (SAT), and $2.5 million for the National Trust's Historic Sites Fund. The House-approved funding levels were $2 million higher than FY'02 enacted levels for the HPF. The full committee mark up of the bill took place on July 9 and affirmed the subcommittee's mark for HPF spending in FY'03. The House passed the Interior Bill by a 377-46 margin on July 17 with amendments.

Unfortunately, the Senate Appropriations Committee marked up the bill on June 27 and remanded the increases provided by the House and reduced the HPF down to $67 million -- the amount provided in the President's FY'03 budget! Under the Senate mark, the entire $2.5 million for the Historic Sites Fund was eliminated, $6 million was cut from the States and $1 million was cut from tribal grants. The Senate did approve the same level of funding for SAT grants -- $30 million. Senate Appropriations Committee Chairman Robert Byrd (D-WV) hopes to bring the Interior bill to the floor in mid-July, leaving preservationists to hope for a better outcome in conference. Not all of the news from the Senate was bad - funding for the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation was increased by $250,000 to $4 million and heritage areas funding received $13.384 million (compared to $14.89 million in the House and only $7.6 million in the President's budget).

Below is a comparison of HPF funding between the House and Senate Interior bills with enacted funding levels in the previous two fiscal years:

Historic Preservation Fund

FY2003 Interior Appropriations Bill (H.R. 5093/S. 2708)

Comparison of House & Senate Mark Up Funding Levels

($ in millions)
Program
FY01
FY02

President's

FY'03

Budget

FY03 House Level
FY'03 Senate Level
States
$46
$39
$34
$40
$34
Tribes
$5.572
$3
$3
$4
$3
SAT
$35
$30
$30
$30
$30
Sites Fund
--
$2.5
$0
$2.5
$0
HPF Totals
$86.5
$74.5
$67
$76.5
$67

Action Needed

Preservation advocates need to contact their Senators and lobby for the House's more favorable funding levels in conference. To assist you in this effort, visit the National Trust's Congressional Advocacy Center at http://capwiz.com/nthp/home/ and click on the alert "Senate Appropriations Committee Cuts HPF!" You can send targeted e-mails to your Senators and ask them to support the House's higher funding levels for the HPF.

back to the top of this page

National Trust Testifies on "Martin's Cove Land Transfer Act"

National Trust vice president for public policy, Kitty Higgins, testified before the House Subcommittee National Parks, Recreation and Public Lands on May 16, regarding the "Martin's Cove Land Transfer Act" (H.R. 4103).

Sponsored by Rep. Jim Hansen (R-UT), H.R. 4103 proposes a land transfer of 940 acres of public lands (owned by the Bureau of Land Management) to the Church of Latter Day Saints for the purpose of preserving the Martin's Cove site in Natrona County, Wyoming. The Martin's Cove area is important to the LDS Church as a historic site because it is where 150 to 200 emigrants of the Willie and Martin handcart companies lost their lives in an early fall snowstorm in 1856 during the Mormon migration. Consequently, the Church has a strong interest in playing a role in interpreting the site. However, the area in question also has a rich history of the western emigration movement for Mormons and non-Mormons alike, as well as Native Americans who resided in this area well before western settlers arrived. For that reason, H.R. 4103 poses a dilemma for policy makers, who must balance stewardship responsibilities imposed by existing federal law on federal agencies with the interests of private entities that want a stake in preserving and interpreting cultural resources important to them as individual groups.

On that point, Ms. Higgins testified that before a land sale/transfer takes place under with a private religious entity such as the LDS Church, appropriate protections for the lands should be incorporated into an easement or protective covenant that will run with the land when it is sold. Higgins also stated that the National Trust would support a co-stewardship agreement between the Bureau of Land Management, the governing federal agency in this case, and the LDS Church whereby lands would continue in public ownership but would be privately managed with all federal protections intact.

For a complete reading of Ms. Higgins testimony and the Trust's position on this legislation, visit http://www.nthp.org/news/docs/20020516_martincove.html.

back to the top of this page

Belle Grove/Cedar Creek National Park Bill Introduced

Representative Frank Wolf (R-VA) and Senator John Warner (R-VA) introduced legislation on June 13 that would designate the Cedar Creek Battlefield and the National Trust's Belle Grove Plantation, a National Historical Park as a unit of the National Park System. H.R. 4944 and S. 2623 provide for the establishment of an endowment with the National Park Foundation and require that "funds to be designated for the interpretation, preservation, and maintenance of the Park resources and public access areas." The bill also establishes a National Park Advisory Committee that would include one representative from the National Trust. In addition, the other nine Civil War battlefield sites within the Shenandoah Valley will benefit from the national park designation in the valley and increase in tourism at the new park, but each battlefield will continue to be protected and managed locally.

The proposed park boundary includes approximately 3,000 acres at the intersection of Frederick, Shenandoah and Warren counties and is based on the 1969 boundary establish for the Cedar Creek and Belle Grove National Historic Landmark. Today, of those 3,000 acres, three private preservation groups, including Belle Grove Plantation, collectively comprise and protect nearly 900 acres within the proposed park boundary.

back to the top of this page

Gephardt Introduces Bill to Enhance Use of State Rehab Tax Credits

House Minority Leader Richard Gephardt (D-MO) has introduced a bill (H.R. 4933) to amend the current tax provision that treats money received from the transfer or refund of state historic rehabilitation tax credits as taxable income. Introduced on June 13, the "Historic Rehabilitation Enhancement Act of 2002" is intended enhance the use and transfer of state rehabilitation tax credits. H.R. 4933 specifically would allow the transfer or disposition of State historic tax credits "with no affect or reduction in the amount of qualified rehabilitation expenditures incurred in connection with a rehabilitated property, nor affect the transfer or disposition, nor any basis adjustments of investment credit property for purposes of the recapture."

The National Trust has sent a letter to Rep. Gephardt endorsing H.R. 4933. Passage of H.R. 4933 would be a boost to state rehab tax credits, which have increasingly come under attack by state legislatures due to budget shortfalls and mandatory state laws that require a balanced budget every year.

back to the top of this page

Senate Finance Committee Approves Charitable Giving Tax Incentives for Gifts of Land

The Senate Finance Committee marked up and approved a bill, the "Charity Aid and Recovery Empowerment Act," containing charitable-giving provisions that provide additional incentives for landowners to donate conservation easements to charities, effective January 1, 2003. These provisions include:

" Up to 50% exclusion of adjusted gross income (AGI) for regular taxpayers who donate conservation easements on land to charities; up to 100% exclusion for farmers and ranchers. Applies to all 170(h) qualifying conservation contributions, including historic ones. It increases deduction to 50% of AGI, with excess contributions carrying over for 15 years. If the taxpayer's income is more than 51% from schedule F, they can deduct up to 100% of their AGI, over that same period.

" An exclusion of 25% of capital gains for sale of property for conservation purposes. There is also an exclusion of 25% of the gain on the sale of real property or an interest in property to any 501(c)(3) or government organization, but historic preservation is, unfortunately, not included in this provision.

back to the top of this page

House Passes Supplemental Brownfields Funding Bill (H.R. 2941)

The House passed a new brownfields funding bill (H.R. 294)1 on June 4 which focuses on providing access to capital for local entities that traditionally have had trouble obtaining financing for brownfields redevelopment activities. Most notably, H.R. 2941 eliminates the requirement that local governments obtain section 108 loan guarantees as a condition to receiving Brownfields Economic Development Initiative (BEDI) grant funding. De-coupling BEDI grants from section 108 loan guarantees is important because some small cities have great difficulty in securing or are unable to secure those guarantees. The new legislation comes on the heels of a larger brownfields funding bill signed into law earlier this year.

H.R. 2941 also establishes a `Pilot Program for National Redevelopment of Brownfields.' With this authority, the Secretary of Housing and Urban Development will be able to fund a common pool for economic development loans available to eligible local governments and distribute these loans on a competitive basis. Because the newly-passed `Small Business Liability Relief and Brownfields Revitalization Act' authorizes only $200 million annually, with a $1 million cap on funds to any individual locality, the Pilot Program is intended to supplement funding for the 450,000 plus brownfields sites across the country. No specific authorization of funding is included in H.R. 2941, but , the Congressional Budget Office estimates that implementing H.R. 2941 would cost $96 million over a five-year period and, out of this amount, $31 million would be used by HUD to establish the aforementioned pilot program to fund redevelopment of brownfields sites.

back to the top of this page

Legislative Updates

Vote on Amending Antiquities Act Postponed Indefinitely in House

Preservation advocates were instrumental in delaying a scheduled vote on the "National Monument Fairness Act" (H.R. 2114) on June 19. Grass roots pressure was essential to the House Rules Committee postponing a vote on H.R. 2114, a bill that would undermine the President's power to declare national monuments and protect and natural and cultural heritage under the Antiquities Act of 1906. The bill would sunset all new national monuments over 50,000 acres within two years of designation unless Congress approves the President's actions. H.R. 2114 fundamentally defeats the very purpose of the Antiquities Act of 1906 and significantly alters the appropriate balance of power between the President and Congress in protecting important federal natural and cultural resources that has served the nation well for more than 90 years.

The Antiquities Act of 1906 has enabled the President to act quickly to protect historic and pre-historic and cultural resources located on the public lands, including sacred Native American sites, pre-historic archaeological resources and sites associated with key figures and events in our nation's history. Most recently, Presidents Clinton and Bush have used the Antiquities Act to designate two of the most significant historic sites in the nation -- Lincoln Cottage National Monument in Washington, D.C., and Governors Island National Monument in New York, respectively -- sites with immeasurable significance to our nation's military and political history.

Advocates should stay tuned for future alerts and updates on possible floor action in the House on H.R. 2114.

back to the top of this page

Airport Capacity Bill (S. 633) Could Spell Trouble for TEA-21 Reauthorization

Preservationists have joined a large coalition of environmental organizations and mounted a grass roots campaign to stop an aviation capacity bill (S. 633) from passing the Senate and possibly setting a bad precedent that could affect the larger highway funding reauthorization of the TEA-21 law next year. S. 633 includes environmental streamlining provisions that, if enacted, could steam roll the environmental review process that protects public health, communities and the environment through state- and local-level review. Advocates began contacting their Senators in June to register their opposition to S. 633 and any other streamlining proposals for airports, highways, pipelines or military bases.

S. 633 was been reported out of the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science and Trasnportation on June 13 and is pending on the Senate Calendar. Advocates can still send their Senators an e-mail through the National Trust's Congressional Advocacy Center at http://capwiz.com/nthp/home/ and register their opposition to S. 633.

back to the top of this page

Boise Mayor Brent Coles Testifies in Support of TEA-21, Transit-Oriented Development in Senate Banking Committee

Brent Coles, the mayor of Boise, Idaho and the President of the U.S. Conference of Mayors, testified before the Senate Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs on June 13 in support of reauthorizing the TEA-21 transportation funding law. Coles' testimony touted TEA-21's successes in supporting collaborative partnerships at the State and local level that have led to developing intermodal transportation projects that embrace concepts such as transit-oriented development. Coles' testimony also pointed out that "the law [TEA-21] has not been completely implemented" and that "despite much progress, we have failed to fully capitalize on the many opportunities this law intended to make available to our cities. I see the reauthorization of the surface transportation program as that opportunity to reach full potential of the law." Mayor Coles' statement can be viewed in full at http://banking.senate.gov/02_06hrg/061302/coles.htm.

back to the top of this page

Funding for Historic Barns Program Sought in FY'03 Appropriations

Language was included in the recently-enacted farm bill (H.R. 2646, P.L. 107-171) that authorizes funding for the rehabilitation and restoration of historic barns. Sen. James Jeffords (I-VT) wrote the historic barns language in the farm bill and also sent a letter on May 15 to Agriculture Appropriations Chairman Herb Kohl (D- WI) and Ranking Minority Member Thad Cochran (R-MS) asking for $5 million in FY 2003 for the program. These funds will be used to provide grants for rehabilitation, repair, fire protection, vandalism prevention, research and identification of historic barn structures.

In addition to Jeffords, the following Senators also signed the letter to Senators Kohl and Cochran: Arlen Specter (R-PA), Richard Lugar (R-IN), Carl Levin (D-MI), Olympia Snowe (R-ME), Bob Smith (R-NH), Blance Lincoln (D-AR), Debbie Stabenow (D-MI), Barbara Mikulski (D-MD), Jon Corzine (D-NJ), Tim Johnson (D-SD), Mark Dayton (D-MN), Christopher Dodd (D-CT), Hillary Rodham Clinton (D-NY), Senator Robert Torricelli (D- NJ), Charles Schumer (D-NY), Jean Carnahan (D-MO), Patrick Leahy (D-VT), Max Cleland (D-GA), Senator Max Baucus (D-MT). Preservation advocates are encouraged to thank these Senators for their support of the barn program.

The Senate Subcommittee on Agriculture, Rural Development and Related Agencies is expected to mark up the FY'03 agriculture spending bill this month.

back to the top of this page

New Authorization Bill (H.R 1606) for Historically Black Colleges and Universities Funding Reported in House

The House Resources Committee reported out a bill (H.R. 1606) on June 20 that would authorize the Secretary of Interior to provide matching grants to rehabilitate historic buildings located on the campuses of the nation's 103 Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs). Introduced by Rep. James Clyburn (D-SC), H.R. 1606 would amend a 1996 omnibus parks bill that provided $29 million for historic preservation activities for HBCUs and create a new funding authorization for HBCU grants while also lowering the matching requirement from 50% to 30% for such grantees.

Unfortunately, HBCUs were only able to realize one-quarter of the original authorization (which expired in FY'01) over a five-year period through congressional appropriations. Rep. Clyburn has championed the cause of HBCU grants and has repeatedly cited a 1998 GAO study that has documented a need of $755 million for 712 historic sites located throughout HBCU campuses nationwide to his congressional colleagues. Clyburn has consistently argued that the 50% matching requirement has not served HBCUs or the crumbling historic sites on these campuses and is instead fostering a policy of deferred demolition.

The National Trust has endorsed H.R. 1606 and Rep. Clyburn's commitment to securing additional HBCU funding in FY'03 and beyond.

back to the top of this page

Announcements

National Trust Announces 2002 Eleven Most Endangered Historic Sites

The National Trust for Historic Preservation Announced 2002 List of America's 11 Most Endangered Historic Places on June 6, 2002. Sites on the 2002 list include:

TEARDOWNS IN HISTORIC NEIGHBORHOODS, Nationwide - Historic neighborhoods across the country are falling prey to an epidemic of teardowns as older homes are being purchased, demolished and replaced by houses that destroy the fabric of communities.

ST. ELIZABETHS HOSPITAL, Washington, D.C. - An architectural marvel opened in the mid-1850s, America's oldest large-scale government-run mental hospital is now crumbling.

ROSENWALD SCHOOLS, Southern U.S. - Between 1913 and 1932, the Rosenwald Fund - founded by Chicago philanthropist Julius Rosenwald - helped build more than 5,300 schools for African Americans, but today, many of these landmarks have disappeared or are falling into ruin.

CHESAPEAKE BAY SKIPJACK FLEET, Maryland - The wooden sailing fleet that has harvested oysters on the Chesapeake Bay for more than a century now numbers only about a dozen, and the vessels are disappearing fast.

POMPEY'S PILLAR, Yellowstone County, Mont. - The place where William Clark, co-leader of the famed Lewis and Clark Expedition, carved his name in stone in 1806 is now threatened by a 100-acre trucking and railroad terminal that will plant four 150-feet tall grain elevators right next door.

HISTORIC BRIDGES OF INDIANA -Built between 1860 and 1930 and made of wood, stone, iron and steel, hundreds of Indiana's historic bridges have been demolished in recent years, and many more are in jeopardy.

MISSOURI RIVER VALLEY CULTURAL AND SACRED SITES, Montana, North Dakota and South Dakota - The valley's archaeological remains and Native American burial sites have been greatly damaged by the federal government's reservoir and dam projects.

GUTHRIE THEATER, Minneapolis, Minn. - The Guthrie, a Twin Cities landmark that revolutionized theater design when it opened in 1963, is scheduled to be demolished and replaced with a parking garage and sculpture garden.

HACKENSACK WATER WORKS, Oradell, N.J. - The 1882 Hackensack Water Works, a marvel of American engineering that has been described as "the history of the Industrial Revolution in one building," is threatened with demolition.

KW'ST'AN SACRED SITES AT INDIAN PASS, Imperial County, Calif. - Filled with panoramic vistas, ancient trails, extensive archaeological sites and petroglyphs, this landscape could soon be defiled by a massive cyanide heap-leach gold mine.

GOLD DOME BANK, Oklahoma City, Okla. - Built in 1958 on historic Route 66, this 150-foot-diameter landmark, an early example of the geodesic dome patented by famed designer and futurist Buckminster Fuller, is facing the wrecking ball.

For more information, call 1-800-315-NTHP or visit the National Trust's web site at http://www.nationaltrust.org/11most.

back to the top of this page

Dozen Distinctive Destinations of 2002 Announced

The National trust announced the selection of its Dozen Distinctive Destinations, an annual list of the best preserved and unique communities in the United States. In announcing the list, National Trust President Richard Moe stated that "each one of these 12 communities represents a truly distinctive slice of America's past that make them exciting alternatives to the homogenization of many other vacation spots. It is my hope that more American cities and towns will follow the lead of these great destinations in preserving their own spirit of place."

The cities and towns on the 2002 list of America's Dozen Distinctive Destinations are:

Asheville, N.C. (pop. 68,889): Home to Biltmore House, America's largest private residence, and the luxurious and historic Grove Park Inn, Asheville also offers diverse natural, historic, and cultural experiences that preserve generations of the "Appalachian tradition."

Butte, Mont. (pop. 33,954): Sitting atop the "richest hill on earth," Butte celebrates its rowdy history and invites visitors to experience a one-of-a-kind urban landscape dotted with well-preserved architecture, abandoned copper mines, mansions of mining millionaires, and more.

Fernandina Beach, Fla. (pop. 10,549): Fernandina Beach offers a residential and commercial mix of late-Victorian architecture in its downtown that reflects the city's great prosperity in the late 1880's, while wide beaches on the east frame the Atlantic Ocean.

Ferndale, Calif. (pop. 1,382): In Ferndale, visitors can stroll along the town's Historic main street District, where art galleries, antique shops and boutiques complement a dazzling array of 19th-century Gothic Revival, Italianate, Eastlake and Queen Anne homes.

Frederick, Md. (pop. 52,767): Located just 48 miles from Washington, D.C., in the rolling hills of central Maryland, vibrant, historic Frederick boasts fine restaurants, art galleries, antique shops galore, more than its share of Revolutionary and Civil War ghosts, and a plucky, long-deceased heroine named Barbara Fritchie.

Holland, Mich. (pop. 35,048): Located on a beautiful lakefront site with a revitalized main street lined with quaint cafes and unique shops, the town is the perfect setting for a weekend getaway or a family vacation.

Milan, Ohio (pop. 1,445): Inventor Thomas Edison was born in this picturesque "New England town in Northwestern Ohio" and in the Edison Birthplace Museum, visitors can view a collection of rare Edisonia, including examples of many of his early inventions, documents and family mementos.

Morristown, N.J. (pop. 18,544): George Washington spent two inhospitable winters here, but today visitors can step back in time while strolling through the town's carefully preserved "green" or admiring the cache of Federal, Greek Revival and Victorian homes that comprise the historic district.

Saratoga Springs, N.Y. (pop. 26,186): Long one of America's premier resorts, culminating in the construction of the historic Gideon Putnam Hotel & Conference Center, the town is filled with dazzling examples of Greek Revival, Gothic Revival and Queen Anne architecture.

Silver City, N.M. (pop. 12,500): Once an Apache Indian campsite, later the boyhood home of the gunslinger Billy the Kid, and most recently a silver mining boomtown, visitors can also discover ancient Native American cultures by visiting the nearby Gila Cliff Dwellings National Monument.

Walla Walla, Wash. (pop. 29,686): A destination rich in historical significance, natural resources, and inherent beauty, Walla Walla boasts a magnificently restored main street, year-round arts and music festivals, events, and many fun opportunities for families with children.

Westerly, R.I. (pop. 17,682): Tucked into Rhode Island's southwest corner, coastal Westerly is one of the state's best-kept secrets with beautiful beaches, sprawling gabled Victorian cottages, vast green lawns and awe-inspiring ocean views.

This is the third year that the National Trust for Historic Preservation has compiled a list of America's Dozen Distinctive Destinations. More than 50 destinations in 27 states were nominated by preservation organizations and local communities.

back to the top of this page

Transportation and Historic Preservation: Items of Interest

* The Public Policy Department has copies of an excellent article from Planning magazine, a publication of the American Planning Association, entitled "Ten Ways to Win with Your State DOT," by Ian Lockwood.

* Public Policy also has copies of a newsletter of the Transportation Research Board's Environment Committee reporting on the committee's 2001 Summer Workshop. Readers who are involved in controversies with their state transportation agencies will be particularly interested in the report of discussions of legal issues transportation officials often face in addressing environmental concerns. Contact Stacey Mahaney at 202-588-6255 or Stacey_Mahaney@nthp.org for a copy of this report.

* The fifth installment of the Surface Transportation Policy Project's (STPP) "Decoding Transportation Policy and Practice" series explains the process that allows states to under- and over-fund federal programs. The newest release explores the implications of the growing loophole on how states are spending federal transportation dollars. To view the series, visit http://www.transact.org/decoders.htm.

back to the top of this page

Americans for National Parks Coalition Sponsors Parks Scrapbook Project

Summer is here and Americans are visiting our national parks in ever-increasing numbers. Americans for National Parks, a coalition of over 200 conservation and preservation groups - including the National Trust - want to capitalize on the popularity of the parks as summer vacation destinations and, as a result, have launched a new tool called the National Scrapbook. The National Scrapbook is a web-based, electronic tool that gives people the opportunity to show their appreciation of our national parks by recording their visits to these great national treasures. As people travel over the summer and visit national parks, they can post photos and written diaries on the scrapbook web site as a way to share experiences and inspire all Americans to care for these majestic places. In September, these posted entries in the scrapbook will be shared with Members of Congress and the president as evidence of public concern and affection for our national parks and support of Americans for National Parks' mission to protect them.

We encourage all preservation advocates to take a moment to visit the National Parks Scrapbook at www.americansfornationalparks.org/scrapbook or send the new flash movie to your members/customers www.npca.org/across_the_nation/americansfornationalparks/safari/.

back to the top of this page

Preservation Advocate News is published by the National Trust's Department of Public Policy and distributed via e-mail to its grass roots advocacy network. For further information contact: National Trust for Historic Preservation, Department of Public Policy, 1785 Massachusetts Avenue, N.W., Washington, DC 20036, 202-588-6254 (phone), 202-588-6038 (fax), policy@nthp.org (e-mail). To sign up directly for e-mail delivery, visit the National Trust's Congressional Advocacy Center at http://capwiz.com/nthp/home/.

Richard Moe, President
Kathryn Higgins, Vice President for Public Policy
Patrick Lally, Director of Congressional Affairs
Staff Writers: Carl Wolf, Dan Costello, Laura Skaggs, Stacey Mahaney

 

Why Preserve | Get Involved | Historic Places | Community Building | Historic Travel | Books and Gifts | Search | Site Map | Home
© 2003 National Trust for Historic Preservation. All rights reserved.  Terms of Use | Privacy Statement