ACEEE PRESS BRIEF
What DOE Didn't Hear: Smart
Energy Policies that Save Money and Cut Pollution through Energy
Efficiency
For further information, contact: Steven Nadel at 202-429-8873
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
April 15, 2002
WASHINGTON, D.C. -- The April 10 AP story ("Cheney
Team Sought Environmentalists") said that in his conversation with
Howard Geller, Director of the American Council for an
Energy-Efficient Economy, DOE staffer Peter Karpoff "noted that
Geller will e-mail 'some stuff.'" Among the "stuff" Geller sent was
the substance of what became an ACEEE report called Smart Energy
Policies: Saving Money and Reducing Pollutant Emissions through
Greater Energy Efficiency. It details nine policy initiatives
-which were mostly ignored in the National Energy Plan.
In what AP
termed the Department of Energy's "cursory, two-day sweep" of input
from sustainable energy experts, it overlooked well-documented,
practical energy efficiency policies that could have made the
President's National Energy Plan more balanced and cost-effective,
and less polluting. "The Administration's energy plan is biased
toward traditional supply policies," stated ACEEE's Executive
Director Steve Nadel. "If DOE had taken the time to fully consider
what we recommend in "Smart Energy Policies," we think our nation's
energy policy would be more balanced, better for the economy, and
better for the environment."
ACEEE's nine
recommended policies are summarized below, along with Administration
and Congressional response to date and an Administration scorecard.
"We would give the Department a 'D+' overall," said Nadel. "While it
has taken positive steps in some areas, it has failed totally on
several important issues and the jury is still out on others. We'd
like to see more substantive action from the Administration on
efficiency."
1. Increase
Vehicle Fuel Economy Standards: Raise federal CAFE standards to 44
mpg for cars and 33 mpg for trucks by 2012. Scorecard:
CAFE not included in NEP; House energy bill (HR4) includes weak
alternative; Senate rejected any real improvement in
CAFE. Overall Administration Grade: Fails
2. Adopt a
National System Benefit Trust Fund: Support state clean energy
programs through a two-tenths of a cent fee on electricity
sales. Scorecard: NEP makes no mention and neither House
of Congress has included such a provision in their energy
bills. Overall Administration Grade: Fails
3. Advance
Appliance Efficiency Standards: Strengthen standards for home
appliances and other equipment like heating and air conditioning
systems, lighting, and electronic products. Scorecard:
Mentioned in the NEP but funding was cut in the 2002 budget while
rollback of air conditioner standard was sought. House bill has
minimal standards provisions; Senate bill goes further on
standards. Overall Administration Grade: C
4. Raise Tax
Incentives for Efficient Buildings, Vehicles, and Equipment:
Increase federal income tax credits, deductions, and other
incentives. Scorecard: Vehicle incentives mentioned in NEP
but no other products. House and Senate bills include broader
efficiency incentives. Overall Administration Grade: D
5. Strengthen
Federal Efficiency R&D: Increase by 17% per year for three
years. Scorecard: NEP described past benefits of R&D
but Administration sought major cuts in 2002 budget. 2003 request is
more balanced but still far short of the need. Overall
Administration Grade: C
6. Promote
Combined Heat and Power: Increase support for this technology since
it reduces the amount of electricity that is lost by conventional
systems, which can be up to two-thirds of the electricity
generated. Scorecard: NEP proposes tax incentives and
improved emissions standards but falls short on interconnection
issues. Both bills address CHP incentives. Overall
Administration Grade: B
7. Initiate
Voluntary Agreements with Industry: Support company plans to reduce
energy use and emissions via federal policies. Scorecard:
NEP silent; Administration later proposed voluntary agreements for
carbon emission reductions; however, no incentives or consequences
for failure were included. Senate bill includes
provision. Overall Administration Grade:
Incomplete
8. Improve
Power Plant Efficiency: Accelerate retirement of older plants via
new Clean Air Act strategies. Scorecard: NEP silent; later
Clear Skies initiative could lead to improved power plant
efficiency; important details incomplete. Overall
Administration Grade: Incomplete
9. Advanced
Building Energy Codes: Increase support for energy codes, an
effective way to make sure new buildings pose minimum strain on
energy resources. Scorecard: Not mentioned in NEP.
Administration cut codes support for states more than
50%. Overall Administration Grade: Fails
"Smart Energy
Policies" is available free of charge at http://www.aceee.org/pubs/e012full.pdf.
#####
About ACEEE:The American Council
for an Energy-Efficient Economy is a non-profit organization
dedicated to advancing energy efficiency as a means of promoting
both economic prosperity and environmental protection. |