| 
                
            
 
 
  
            July 26 
              
            SUPPORT S. 2760, PRESERVE STOCK OPTIONS FOR 
            RANK-AND-FILE 
            Senators Enzi, Lieberman, and others, have filed a 
            bill, S. 2760, the "Stock Options Fairness and Accountability Act," 
            which would direct the SEC to study all of the issues involved with 
            stock options and make recommendations. Following are reasons to 
            support this bill.  
            The Enzi-Lieberman bill prevents a rush to judgment 
            that would kill stock options. The "Stock Options Fairness and 
            Accountability Act" (S. 2760) filed by Senators Enzi, Lieberman, 
            Allen, Boxer, Burns. Frist, Feinstein and Ensign, would direct the 
            SEC to conduct a thorough study not only of the accounting issues, 
            but also other public policy issues in the stock options debate, 
            such as whether the valuation models work, the impact expensing will 
            have on the availability of options to both rank-and-file workers 
            and senior executive and whether investors would be better served by 
            having enhanced disclosures of the details of a firm’s stock options 
            plans. The SEC has the authority, expertise and credibility to 
            conduct such an expanded study. The Enzi-Lieberman bill provides a 
            more reasonable and appropriate vehicle for resolution of the stock 
            option accounting debate.  
            Vote "No" on amendments offered by Senators McCain 
            and Levin. 
            Senators Levin and McCain have indicated that they 
            intend to offer stock options amendments to any and every available 
            legislative vehicle. Senator McCain’s proposed amendment would 
            require that companies treat stock options as an expense for 
            financial reporting purposes. Senator Levin’s proposed amendment 
            would require that the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) 
            study the issue and enact an appropriate standard within 12-months. 
            These proposals will end stock options for rank-and-file workers and 
            preserve them for senior executives.  
            
              - Senator McCain’s amendment would directly legislate an 
              accounting standard
 . Congress should not get involved in the 
              business of setting accounting standards. Fed Chairman Alan 
              Greenspan told the Senate Banking Committee that Congress should 
              do nothing on stock options. There is broad disagreement over 
              whether expensing of stock options is appropriate. Many experts 
              believe that expensing stock options would only mislead investors 
              and give them an inaccurate picture of a firm’s financial 
              position. Just because options might be a form of compensation 
              does not mean that they ought to be expensed like other forms of 
              compensation. 
              - Senator Levin’s Amendment would direct the FASB to study 
              the appropriateness of expensing stock options only from an 
              accounting standpoint. There is more to the stock options 
              accounting debate than just the technical accounting theory. 
              Before any final decision is made on expensing stock options, 
              there should be a study of issues that is more thorough than 
              Senator Levin proposes; nor should FASB be compelled to study 
              issues outside its competence. Congress recently enacted 
              legislation purporting to make FASB independent. It would be 
              ironic indeed for the next bill to tell FASB what to do and when 
              to do it. 
  
              
               
            This page was last updated on 07/29/02. 
              Copyright © 2001 American Electronics Association. 
             All rights reserved.    |