Copyright 2002 Journal Sentinel Inc. Milwaukee
Journal Sentinel (Wisconsin)
January 17, 2002 Thursday FINAL EDITION
SECTION: SPORTS; Pg. 01C
LENGTH:
1033 words
HEADLINE: Title IX is taken to
task; MU wrestlers part of suit filed in Washington
BYLINE: LORI NICKEL AND NAHAL TOOSI of the Journal Sentinel
staff
BODY: The National Wrestling
Coaches Association, along with the defunct wrestling club team at Marquette
University, filed a lawsuit Wednesday in U.S. District Court for the District of
Columbia in Washington D.C. against the Department of Education. The lawsuit
challenges the proportionality rule of Title IX and the way the federal law is
enforced.
Marquette University itself is not involved
in the lawsuit. The team's former participants and alumni supporters are named
as plaintiffs, with the NWCA as the lead plaintiff.
This marks the first suit brought against the federal government over
Title IX by an athletic association since the National Collegiate Athletic
Association sued unsuccessfully in 1976.
Past lawsuits
over Title IX have been filed by student athletes against individual schools to
protect or reinstate athletic programs that were cut over Title IX. Not one of
those lawsuits has been successful.
"The immediate
objective is to remove the gender quota," said Eric Pearson, the co-chair of the
Title IX committee of the NWCA.
In
1996, Title IX's enforcement laws were toughened. Title IX prohibits sex discrimination in education by
institutions that receive federal funding. Schools had to comply with the 1972
federal law in one of three ways: by showing a recent history of adding women's
athletic teams, by proving that the interests of the student body were being
met, or by proportionality.
Proportionality doesn't
count the number of opportunities available to men and women, but rather the
actual number of individual men and women competing in sports.
"Many universities feel the only way to avoid a sure lawsuit is to use
this proportionality interpretation," said NWCA's executive director of three
years, Mike Moyer. "We would like to see decisions made truly on accommodating
the interests of the students."
For example, if there
are 40 spots available on the men's baseball team, there should be 40 spots
available on the women's softball team, according to the NWCA.
Instead, with the proportionality rule of Title IX, the individuals on
rosters are counted. Using the same example as above, if only 20 women show up
to make that 40-woman roster softball team, then in most cases only 20 men would
be allowed to play on the baseball team, even if 40 men were interested.
Proportionality is supposed to reflect the gender makeup
of the student body. Theoretically, if there are 51% female students on campus,
then 51% of the school's athletes should be female.
Wrestling program hit
Marquette University's
men's wrestling program was cut from the athletic department budget in 1994. The
program continued, at the varsity level, by private funding through school
alumni.
Because the male participants, more than 30,
skewed the overall number of male-to-female athletes at Marquette, and Marquette
has to comply with Title IX to remain NCAA certified, it dropped wrestling.
That was an unsportsmanlike takedown, according to Brock
Warder, of Sioux City, Iowa. He is a senior wrestler at Marquette University.
"Male athletics are being cheated simply because of Title
IX," said Warder. "This is for my teammates who have had their career cut short.
They had a tremendous amount of talent and were not given a chance, and it's
sad."
With Marquette's program dead, there is just one
Division I wrestling program left in the state, the University of Wisconsin, and
one Division II program, the University of Wisconsin-Parkside.
The NWCA lawsuit said that such quotas have caused schools like
Marquette to slash male athletic programs and were a form of reverse
discrimination.
"I would like to see how this case goes
through. It's a pretty impressive group of lawyers," said Jim Schmitz, who
wrestled at Marquette for four years before he coached the Golden Eagles for
12.
"We did a lot of great things at Marquette. We had
two NCAA qualifiers the year before our funding was cut. I'm really proud of the
people we brought in and the wrestlers who graduated. It's odd that it was
pushed out because of laws and rules interpretations and budget reasons."
Taking a new tack
In 1976, after
a failed attempt to get Congress to support legislation that would exclude
athletics from Title IX, the NCAA sued what was then the Department of Health,
Education and Welfare, charging that the department should not oversee
intercollegiate athletics. That case was dismissed.
However, the wrestling suit marks the first time the government is
being challenged over the three-pronged compliance part of Title IX, said Larry
Joseph, the lead attorney for the plaintiffs.
Joseph
said the case differed from previous Title IX lawsuits because it challenged the
Department of Education's rules on certain procedural grounds. The plaintiffs
contend -- among numerous other items -- that because no U.S. president or
attorney general signed off on the department's Title IX rules that they have no
force or effect.
"The department needs to bring its
policy up to date," Joseph said. "Most schools probably were discriminating in
the 1970s and some schools probably still are discriminating against women
today. The difference is that there are now schools treating students equally
and some where it's tilted the other way, against men."
One major advocate of Title IX, the National Women's Law Center, is
calling the lawsuit unoriginal and saying it is doomed to fail.
TITLE IX LAWSUIT A COMPARISON
The National
Wrestling Coaches Association is suing the federal Department of Education over
Title IX's proportionality issues. Marquette is one of three schools named as a
party to the suit. Here's a comparison of the number of athletes competing in
athletics in 1981-'82 and 1999-2000:
74,239 Combined
number of female athletes at Divisions I, II and III schools in 1981-'82.
169,800 Number of male athletes.
363 Number of wrestling programs in Divisions I, II and III.
7,914 Number of wrestlers.
150,185 Combined number of female athletes at Divisions I, II and III
schools in 1999-2000.
210,989 Number of male
athletes.
234 Number of wrestling programs in Divisions
I, II and III.