Political Science 540, American National Institutions,
Spring 2000
Prof. Frank Baumgartner
Questions and discussion topics for week 6, February 12:
Readings: Various articles on committees, Krehbiel, Pivotal
Politics
Choose one of these topics for a five page paper if you
choose to do one this week. In any case, come to class prepared to discuss the
following:
- Explain the logic of the distributional view of
committees. Explain the logic of the party-centered view. Why would the
parties allow the committees to deviate from their preferred policies? Why
would the chamber as a whole allow a subset to deviate?
- Explain and evaluate the evidence used in this
debate.
- Review the evidence presented in the JOP paper. What
is the significance of studying issues rather than studying committees as
most have done?
- Note the reliance on roll-call voting studies.
Suggest alternatives and the relative merits of studying these issues with
other methods.
- Krehbiel’s more recent book provides a general theory
of the impact of institutional rules on congressional behavior. Evaluate
the usefulness of the theory.
- Krehbiel is always careful with his methods. Evaluate
his evidence. What more could one do to test this theory?